Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Saturday November 9 2024
The Trump-Poilievre Paradox – Rhetoric vs. Reality in Canadian Conservatism
September 20, 2024
Comparing Pierre Poilievre to Donald Trump has become a favoured theme in Canadian political discourse. For partisan critics, it’s an easy play: conjuring images of Trump evokes associations with divisive rhetoric, populist slogans, and even authoritarian tendencies. But Poilievre, despite a shared knack for populist sloganeering and a confrontational style, remains distinct from Trump in meaningful ways. With Trump’s recent victory drawing renewed scrutiny to his influence on conservative politics worldwide, the question looms: how close will Poilievre align with Trump’s policies, and where will he resist?
Both leaders have indeed tapped into a deep well of frustration among working-class voters. Trump, with his “Make America Great Again” mantra, speaks to a nostalgic longing for a time when American manufacturing and middle-class prosperity seemed more attainable. Poilievre’s echo of this approach, encapsulated in the phrase “Axe the Tax,” is a rallying cry for Canadians feeling the pinch of inflation, rising housing costs, and stagnant wages. Poilievre has also sharpened his rhetoric with personal barbs — branding Prime Minister Justin Trudeau as “Just-inflation” and NDP leader Jagmeet Singh as “Sell-out Singh” — signalling a shift in tone not typically associated with Canadian conservatism.
Essay: Canada’s polite Trumpism
September 4, 2024
Yet for all the parallels in style, there are substantial policy distinctions between the two. Trump’s appeal to his base has often been accompanied by polarizing stances, such as his hardline approach to immigration and his embrace of protectionist trade policies. These policies tapped into a strand of nationalism and nativism that has, so far, found limited resonance in Canada’s broader political landscape. Poilievre, on the other hand, has focused his populist appeal more narrowly on economic issues, particularly around affordability and cost of living. His promises to repeal the carbon tax and address the housing crisis are aimed at the specific economic anxieties of Canadians, rather than broader cultural divisions.
Poilievre’s support of the working-class “freedom” movement, especially during the trucker convoy protests, may be as close as he gets to the culture war themes that underpin much of Trump’s base. While Poilievre openly criticized Trudeau’s handling of the protest, siding with workers who felt ignored by Ottawa, he has been cautious not to echo Trump’s more overt attacks on institutions like the media or judiciary. This restraint signals a departure from Trump’s relentless strategy of painting himself as a political outsider fighting a “deep state” that seeks to undermine him. Instead, Poilievre has framed himself as a necessary disruptor within the bounds of Canada’s parliamentary norms.
Opinion: No, Pierre Poilievre is not Donald Trump
November 9, 2023
The challenge for Poilievre now is to balance his populist, anti-elite appeal with a more inclusive vision for a diverse Canada. He has made overtures to immigrant communities, refraining from nativist rhetoric and positioning himself as a champion for those who feel “left behind” by Liberal policies. Yet critics argue that his anti-tax, pro-business policies may ultimately benefit the wealthy more than the working-class Canadians he’s courting. Poilievre, like Trump, risks alienating moderate voters if his slogans feel like hollow gestures to those seeking real solutions.
In navigating this path, Poilievre may ultimately use Trump’s example as a cautionary tale rather than a roadmap. Trump’s second victory, driven by working-class disillusionment, reminds conservatives worldwide of the power of populist rhetoric. But in a country as diverse as Canada, with a political culture less prone to polarization, a hardline Trumpian approach is likely a losing formula. Poilievre’s brand of conservatism may flirt with some of Trump’s tactics, but his policy choices suggest a more tempered form of populism that resists Trump’s most divisive instincts.
September 9, 2023
While Canada’s political landscape evolves, Poilievre faces a choice: adopt a broad, solutions-oriented populism, or lean further into the fiery style that Trump has perfected south of the border. For now, he seems intent on cherry-picking Trump’s rhetorical strategies, without adopting policies that would alienate the moderates who hold the balance of power in Canadian elections. Whether this will resonate with Canadian voters — or eventually backfire — will shape the future of Canada’s Conservative Party and its place in the country’s political spectrum.
For a Deep Dive into what this cartoon represents along with the other cartoons drawn in the past week and the earlier years of Trump have a listen to this convincing, though admittedly overly fawning podcast featuring two robot humans.
For a written piece, head on over to “The Graeme Gallery” at SubStack, and if you haven’t already done so, please subscribe!
Post Election Blues
When the Elephant Stirs: When they go red, we go blue