Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Friday June 27, 2025
Also published in the Toronto Star. Posted to Reddit.
Poilievre’s Diminishing Shadow
May 1, 2025
As we embark on the second month since Mark Carney’s resounding victory in the federal election, the contrast between his leadership style and that of Pierre Poilievre has never been more stark. Carney has quickly established himself as a formidable leader, uniting the provinces with his ambitious Build Strong policy encapsulated in Bill C5. This initiative has sparked cooperation and optimism among premiers across Canada, setting a constructive tone that resonates with citizens.
In contrast, Pierre Poilievre’s leadership appears increasingly out of step with the current political climate. Known for his negative and contentious approach, Poilievre has often been criticized for focusing more on tearing down opponents than on proposing viable solutions. His alignment with Donald Trump’s rhetoric, particularly the “Canada First” ideology and opposition to diversity, equity, and inclusion, alienated many Canadian voters. These positions seemed tone-deaf to the values of inclusivity and global cooperation that many Canadians hold dear.
News: Pierre Poilievre has dropped out of the spotlight. What happens when he comes back?
September 16, 2023
Poilievre’s greatest political success might have been his ability to criticize and demean Justin Trudeau, which once translated into a surge in popularity. However, this strategy has proven insufficient against Carney, who has swiftly demonstrated the effectiveness of a moderate and centrist approach. Carney’s leadership style has been characterized by a commitment to Canada’s sovereignty and identity, as evidenced by his deft handling of Trump’s 51st state rhetoric and his reinforcement of Canada’s constitutional monarchy. The symbolic reading of the Throne Speech by the King further cemented Canada’s distinct national identity.
Moreover, Carney’s commitment to bolstering Canada’s defence and his adeptness in fostering international partnerships were showcased during the successful G7 summit he hosted. These achievements have elevated Canada’s standing on the global stage and underscored Carney’s ability to lead with both vision and pragmatism.
Analysis: Poilievre sets himself the easiest by-election test — ever
January 3, 2025
In comparison, Poilievre’s recent defeat and loss of his parliamentary seat have left him appearing small and increasingly irrelevant. His determination to cling to power might be seen by some as admirable, but it also smacks of desperation. The Conservative Party’s alignment with populism and Trump-lite rhetoric under Poilievre has led many to question whether he represents the future the party desires.
As Canadians look to leaders who can address the complex challenges of our time with nuance and foresight, Poilievre’s contentious style and lack of constructive engagement seem increasingly out of place. In this new era of Canadian politics, marked by collaboration and thoughtful leadership, Pierre Poilievre’s approach feels like a relic of a bygone era—one that is ill-suited to meet the demands of the present and future.