Author: Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Tuesday May 12 2025

Mark Carney’s Rodeo: Can He Tame the Bull of Western Alienation and the Beast Across the Border?

Mark Carney’s entry into the political arena as Canada’s Prime Minister is akin to stepping into a rodeo ring, preparing to ride the proverbial angry bull of Western alienation. With a mandate from the recent election, Carney finds himself in a unique position to distinguish his leadership from the fraught relations that characterized his predecessor Justin Trudeau’s tenure, particularly with Alberta and Saskatchewan.

The political landscape Carney inherits is fraught with tension. Alberta and Saskatchewan’s grievances are deeply rooted in economic and political realities that have been exacerbated by federal policies perceived as dismissive of their contributions. The historical parallels with the 1930s, as highlighted in John Turley-Ewart’s article, show that ignoring these economic roots risks deepening the rift. Premier Danielle Smith’s openness to a referendum on Alberta’s independence underscores the urgency of addressing these concerns.

News: Alberta’s separatist angst has bone-deep economic roots. Ottawa cannot ignore it

Carney’s recent election victory provides him with the leverage to reset relations with the West. Unlike Trudeau, whose relationship with Alberta was often marked by conflict over environmental policies and energy sector restrictions, Carney has the opportunity to approach the provinces with a fresh perspective. His background as a central banker and advocate for green energy positions him uniquely to balance the need for economic stability with environmental commitments.

The advice from Marcus Gee suggests that Carney should focus on the strengths of Canadian federalism, emphasizing cooperation and decentralization. By showcasing how federalism can effectively address regional concerns, Carney can work towards mitigating separatist sentiments. His challenge will be to implement pragmatic policies that support a transition to renewable energy while recognizing the economic significance of the oil and gas industry.

Opinion: Carney rode a wave of national pride into office. Now he’s tasked with quelling rising separatism

Complicating Carney’s rodeo ride is the situation in the United States under Donald Trump, which poses its own set of challenges. The strained U.S.-Canada relations impact economic stability and require strategic diplomacy. Carney must balance Canada’s environmental goals with economic realities, leveraging Canada’s natural resources to strengthen economic ties amidst U.S. tariffs and protectionist policies. The unity required to address internal grievances must extend to a coherent national strategy for navigating the complexities of international relations.

Colby Cosh’s perspective that Alberta’s separatist movement is weak offers Carney some breathing room. However, the underlying support for separation cannot be ignored. Carney must navigate these sentiments carefully, ensuring that his government’s actions speak louder than words. His engagement with provincial leaders, as noted in reader comments, is a promising start, but it must translate into tangible outcomes that address both economic and political grievances.

Opinion: Colby Cosh: Alberta’s feeble separatist movement

Carney’s rodeo ride is not just about taming the bull of Western alienation but also managing the beast across the border. The stakes are high, and the challenge is multifaceted. Can he temper these forces? Only time will tell. What is clear is that Carney must harness the leverage of his fresh mandate to build bridges, promote dialogue, and demonstrate that Canadian federalism is not just a theoretical success but a practical one that can adapt to the needs of all its provinces while navigating complex international landscapes.

In this rodeo, Carney must hold on tight, navigate with skill, and ultimately steer Canada towards a future where regional grievances are heard, addressed, and resolved, and international relations are managed with finesse. His success or failure in this endeavour will define his legacy and the future of Canadian unity.

---