Thursday August 1, 2024
Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Thursday August 1, 2024
Link to the animated making-of clip of this cartoon.
J.D. Vance—Trump’s Liability in 2024
J.D. Vance, once seen as a strategic vice-presidential pick to bolster Trump’s appeal among the Republican base, has quickly turned into a significant liability. This sentiment is echoed by Maureen Dowd, Andrew Coyne, and Justin Webb, who collectively highlight Vance’s controversial views and missteps.
Andrew Coyne vividly characterizes Vance as a “smarter Trump,” noting that while Trump has always been defined by his “venomous ignorance,” Vance embodies a more calculated, yet equally problematic form of extremism. According to Coyne, Vance’s “wooden” demeanor and “bookish smarm” have bored and confused audiences, exacerbated by his past remarks that have alienated not just liberals but many Republicans as well. Coyne argues that Vance’s failure lies in his attempt to be the smart, strategic successor to Trump, which ironically makes him a greater liability. Unlike Trump, whose ignorance acts as a form of invulnerability, Vance’s calculated opportunism and lack of humility have made him a target for criticism.
Opinion: A smarter Trump turns out to be a weaker force
Maureen Dowd provides a starkly critical view of both Trump and Vance, suggesting that Trump’s own retrograde attitudes towards women are outdone by Vance’s “draconian and mean-spirited” views. Dowd describes Trump as stuck in a “1959 time warp,” marked by outdated and offensive perspectives on women, but Vance’s views, according to her, are even more egregious. She highlights Vance’s dismissal of women who don’t fit his traditional mold, arguing that his belief that only women in traditional marriages have a “direct stake” in America is not just archaic but “un-American.”
Dowd also criticizes Vance for his attempt to sanitize his previous derogatory comments about women, which he dismissed as mere sarcasm. She portrays Vance as embodying a modern-day “faux-billy” who tailors his beliefs to match his ambitions while projecting an image nurtured by extremist ideologies. His stance on issues like abortion and his promotion of policies targeting women’s rights further underscore his unsuitability.
Opinion: JD Vance, Purr-fectly Dreadful
Moreover, the unexpected nomination of Kamala Harris to replace Joe Biden has added to Trump’s woes. Harris has invigorated the Democratic base, as observed by Webb, presenting a sharp contrast to the Trump-Vance ticket. Harris’s campaign has gained momentum, while Trump’s appears directionless, unable to effectively counter Harris’s growing appeal.
However, Harris’s current momentum could easily be whittled down with gaffes and the inevitable dirty campaigning as time goes on. The Democratic Party’s fortunes also depend on Harris’s imminent choice of a running mate, which could further strengthen her campaign. A strong vice-presidential pick could solidify her position and highlight the eroding appeal of J.D. Vance.
Analysis: Kamala Harris has rattled Trump. Things could get really ugly
Reader reactions to Webb’s piece reinforce the notion that Trump and Vance are out of touch. Trump lacks essential qualities like wit, warmth, and wisdom, making his attacks on Harris seem desperate and out of place. Vance, meanwhile, exacerbates the situation with his own misjudgments, making him a poor choice for attracting swing voters.
As Harris rallies support and assembles a strong campaign team, Trump and Vance seem increasingly isolated. The “childless cat ladies” demographic, underestimated by Vance, might very well play a crucial role in the upcoming election, potentially tipping the scales against the Republicans. The combined effect of Vance’s unpopularity and Harris’s rising profile suggests that the GOP’s strategy is faltering, making it an uphill battle for Trump in November. (AI)