2024-04 – mackaycartoons

Tuesday February 27, 2024

February 27, 2024 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Tuesday February 27, 2024

The Taxing Reality: Navigating Canada’s Complicated Tax System

March 27, 2023

As Canadians gear up for another tax season, the reality of our complex and burdensome tax system is hitting home harder than ever. The sticker shock of expenses and the painstaking process of crunching numbers have left many wondering, “Am I really better off than I was five years ago?” For most, the answer seems to be a resounding “no.”

The Trudeau government’s promise to have the backs of the middle class appears to be wearing thin. The supposed mantra of “we’ve got Canadians’ backs” feels more like a hollow slogan when confronted with the ever-increasing tax burdens and the rising cost of living. It’s a bitter pill to swallow when the mantra shifts from “work to live” to a more ominous “live to work” just to keep up with the Joneses.

Illustrating the absurdity of our tax system is our editorial cartoon featuring “Reap and Thoreau Tax Consultants.” A scruffy, fur-wrapped individual, armed with snowshoes and a stick, hands over a tax return package with a smirk, suggesting the solution to the complexity is a radical embrace of the “Drop out of Society Pioneer” lifestyle.

News: The 2024 tax season has kicked off – Here’s what you need to know

January 20, 2023

The New Zealand approach to taxes highlights how much simpler the process could be. Cross-referencing existing information, they automatically calculate tax returns, sparing citizens the bureaucratic labyrinth that is the Canadian tax system. The Auditor General’s revelation that CRA call centres provide incorrect information nearly 30% of the time further underscores the convoluted nature of our tax process.

The Trudeau government’s promise of free, automatic tax filing for simple returns remains unfulfilled, leaving taxpayers drowning in paperwork. One-time payouts like the Grocery Rebate and the Canada Dental Benefit require meticulous tax filing, creating additional hurdles for citizens already grappling with an intricate system.

The Montreal Economic Institute’s critique points out that the Canadian tax system is among the costliest in OECD countries. Despite acknowledging the problem, little has been done to simplify it. Even the Conservative government before Trudeau’s Liberals failed to alleviate the burden.

The complexity of the tax system is not just a bureaucratic inconvenience; it’s a significant financial burden. The Fraser Institute estimated that, factoring in time, accounting fees, and software costs, Canadians pay about $500 each just to fulfill their tax obligations.

While the United States faces a similar issue, driven in part by lobbying from tax-filing companies, Canada’s situation appears to be rooted in an unwillingness to simplify a tax code that hasn’t seen substantial changes in over 50 years. The number of tax credits and benefits continues to increase, making the system even more intricate.

Even Chartered Professional Accountants Canada, among the primary beneficiaries of the complex tax code, acknowledges that the system has gone too far. The bureaucratic hurdles prevent benefits from reaching low-income individuals, adding an extra layer of injustice to an already flawed system.

News: Canadian taxes aren’t just high, they’re needlessly complicated to file

October 12, 2017

As the 2024 tax season kicks off, Canadians are left grappling with changes and additions, such as the FHSA deductions and alterations to home office claims. The comments from disgruntled taxpayers underlining the lack of transparency and accountability in the tax system echo a sentiment that resonates with many.

It’s time for tax reform to be a top priority. A move towards a flat income tax and a reduction in capital gains tax could stimulate investment and simplify the lives of hardworking Canadians. The tax system, which began as a temporary measure to fund WWI, has grown into an unmanageable behemoth. The social engineering aspect of the tax system further complicates matters, emphasizing the need for a fundamental shift in our approach.

As Canadians face yet another taxing season, it’s clear that the current system is not working for the middle class. The promise of a simplified, streamlined process seems distant, leaving taxpayers to navigate a labyrinth of paperwork and confusion. It’s time for politicians to take action and prioritize the needs of the people over the complexities of an outdated tax code.

Saturday February 24, 2024

February 24, 2024 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Saturday February 24, 2024

Doug Ford’s “Get It Done” Act: A Gimmick in Environmental Clothing

Series: Young Doug Ford

Premier Doug Ford’s introduction of the Get It Done Act has raised eyebrows and drawn criticism from various quarters, and for good reason. While the government’s intent to expedite infrastructure projects is commendable, the bill appears to be more of a political gimmick than a comprehensive solution. The legislation, echoing the campaign slogan of “Get It Done,” seeks to streamline environmental assessments for highways and hasten expropriation processes, but its broader implications are cause for concern.

The bill’s primary focus on fast-tracking major infrastructure projects, especially highways, raises questions about its alignment with Ontario’s environmental priorities. The decision to categorize highways as “low risk” for rapid environmental approvals seems shortsighted, potentially sacrificing thorough assessments for expediency. Critics argue that the emphasis on projects like Highway 413 distracts from pressing issues such as healthcare, affordable housing, and education.

News: Ontario omnibus bill ‘Get It Done Act’ to contain urban boundary changes

February 22, 2024

Environmentalists and opposition leaders, including Green Party leader Mike Schreiner and NDP leader Marit Stiles, have voiced reservations about the bill. Schreiner labels it the “Get It Done Wrong Act,” emphasizing the government’s misplaced priorities. Stiles expresses concerns about the government “tinkering around” with vital processes and questions its ability to listen to the needs of the people.

The claim that the bill aims to make life more affordable for families and businesses by streamlining processes seems disconnected from its actual provisions. Freezing the fee for renewing a driving license, a seemingly unrelated measure, is thrown into the mix, further diluting the bill’s focus and raising questions about its coherence.

However, it’s essential to acknowledge instances where Premier Ford has demonstrated collaboration and effectiveness in governance. Recently, the City of Toronto received over $100 million from the Ford government as a reward for surpassing housing targets. Premier Ford and Mayor Olivia Chow jointly announced the funding, highlighting Toronto’s accomplishment in breaking ground on 50% more houses than required.

News: Ontario gives Toronto $114M for exceeding its 2023 housing targets

June 28, 2023

This collaborative approach in addressing housing challenges is commendable, showcasing a positive aspect of Premier Ford’s administration. Encouraging other municipalities to emulate Toronto’s success in meeting housing targets is a step in the right direction, fostering a sense of shared responsibility among local leaders.

While Premier Doug Ford’s “Get It Done” Act may be seen as a politically charged move to fulfill campaign promises, its focus on expediting environmental assessments for highways raises concerns about environmental stewardship. On the flip side, the collaborative efforts with Mayor Olivia Chow on housing initiatives demonstrate the potential for constructive governance. Striking a balance between expediency and environmental responsibility is crucial for Ontario’s future, and the government must carefully consider the long-term implications of its legislative actions. (AI)

Friday February 22, 2024

February 23, 2024 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Friday February 22, 2024

Yulia Navalnaya: A Beacon of Hope Amidst Putin’s Darkness

In the aftermath of Alexei Navalny’s suspicious death, the world grapples with the continued malevolence of Vladimir Putin and the withering strength of Ukraine’s resistance against his invading army. Amidst this grim reality, a beacon of hope emerges in the form of Yulia Navalnaya, the widow of the slain Russian dissident.

Yulia Navalnaya’s strength has not gone unnoticed. For years, she stood steadfastly by her husband’s side, a constant presence at political protests and court hearings. When Alexei Navalny was poisoned in 2020, it was Yulia who fought for clearance to fly him abroad for life-saving treatment. Now, as she faces the daunting challenge of navigating life without her husband, she boldly places herself in the political spotlight.

In a powerful video statement, Yulia Navalnaya articulates her grief, fury, and determination to carry on her husband’s cause. Her love for Alexei and her commitment to realizing his vision of a “beautiful Russia of the future” shine through the pain. For those despondent Russians opposing Putin, Yulia’s impassioned speech provides a glimmer of hope in an otherwise bleak landscape.

Yulia Navalnaya’s emergence as a strong and compelling figure parallels the experiences of other formidable women who have stepped into the void left by absent men in oppressive regimes. From Svetlana Tikhanovskaya in Belarus to Evgenia Kara-Murza, these women have demonstrated resilience and tenacity in the face of adversity.

While Yulia Navalnaya may currently be abroad, her voice resonates globally. Addressing EU foreign ministers, she has already garnered international support and condemnation for Putin’s role in her husband’s death. Yet, the challenges within Russia are immense, with Navalny’s political organization banned and opposition figures facing systematic oppression.

Opinion (despite omission of Yulia, giving inspiration in the above cartoon): Alexei Navalny’s untimely death has cut short his mission. Here’s how nations can take up his call

February 13, 2024

The world must not overlook the significance of Yulia Navalnaya’s call to unite against the Putin regime. Her plea for people to “punch hard” at the oppressive forces resonates with the quiet and peaceful resistance seen in the piles of flowers at memorials to Navalny across Russia.

In this critical moment, nations must heed Navalny’s call for more military support to Ukraine. It is imperative to recognize the importance of hope in the face of receding strength. Yulia Navalnaya embodies that hope, and her courageous stance should inspire a collective resolve to stand against the ruthless Vladimir Putin. In supporting Ukraine and embracing the hope symbolized by Yulia, the world can honour Alexei Navalny’s legacy and resist the darkness that threatens to engulf us all. (AI)

Thursday February 22, 2024

February 22, 2024 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Thursday February 22, 2024

Doug Ford’s ‘Get It Done’ Act: A Distraction from Real Issues

January 23, 2024

As Premier Doug Ford proudly presents his “Get It Done Act” to the Ontario legislature, it becomes increasingly clear that this omnibus bill is more of a political maneuver than a genuine effort to address the pressing problems facing the province.

The legislation, borrowing its title from Ford’s 2022 election slogan, aims to streamline infrastructure projects, eliminate fees, and impose restrictions on future carbon taxes and tolls. However, the opposition parties have dismissed it as performative, with good reason.

News: Doug Ford hopes to finally ‘Get It Done’ when legislature resumes Tuesday

One glaring issue is the misalignment between Ford’s proclaimed priorities and the actual challenges plaguing Ontario. While the Premier is busy pushing for expedited construction and cost-of-living concerns, the real crises in healthcare and housing continue to be overlooked.

October 22, 2022

The proposed urban boundary changes, although claimed to be in response to municipal requests, raise questions about the government’s commitment to effective and consultative policymaking. It appears that reversals and policy U-turns have become the norm, showcasing a lack of strategic planning.

The headline-grabbing elements of the bill, such as the carbon pricing referendum and the ban on new tolls, appear more as political tactics than practical solutions. Opposition leaders rightly point out the performative nature of these measures, emphasizing their potential to be easily undone by a future government.

The skepticism is further fuelled by Ford’s selective memory. While he adamantly opposes carbon taxes now, he conveniently forgets that Ontarians were exempt from the federal levy until his government canceled the cap-and-trade alliance, costing the provincial treasury $2 billion annually.

November 12, 2021

The focus on a carbon pricing referendum and toll bans seems more like a desperate attempt to divert attention from ongoing controversies, such as the Greenbelt land swap scandal and the $8.28-billion Greenbelt debacle under RCMP investigation.

What’s truly disheartening is the disregard for critical issues like healthcare. The shortage of family doctors, overcrowded hospitals, and the burnout of healthcare workers should be at the forefront of any government’s agenda. Yet, Ford’s “Get It Done Act” seems to turn a blind eye to the real needs of Ontarians.

News: Meet some of the 6 million Canadians who don’t have a family doctor

As the Premier tries to deflect attention with performative policies, it’s essential for Ontarians to see through the political posturing and demand real solutions to the problems that affect their daily lives. The “Get It Done Act” may sound promising, but actions speak louder than slogans, and it’s time for the government to prioritize substance over optics.

Wednesday February 21, 2024

February 21, 2024 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Wednesday February 21, 2024

ArriveCan Debacle: A Lesson in Leadership and Accountability

April 9, 2021

It’s a question many Canadians are asking: How did the ArriveCan app, a seemingly straightforward project, turn into a $59.5 million financial maze? The recent report from Auditor General Karen Hogan sheds light on the glaring mismanagement and financial chaos surrounding the development of ArriveCan.

As we navigate through the aftermath of this debacle, it’s essential to examine the broader context and acknowledge the responsibilities at the top. In the early days of the pandemic, when governments worldwide were hastily reacting to the unfolding health crisis, the Trudeau government faced the challenge of implementing crucial programs and initiatives to support individuals and businesses.

Opinion: How did ArriveCan debacle go so wrong?

Thursday August 19, 2021

However, the ArriveCan fiasco stands out for its scale of mismanagement, leaving Auditor General Karen Hogan and her team struggling to make sense of the financial chaos. The report points to a staggering $59.5 million spent on the app, with poor financial records and control on the part of the Canada Border Services Agency making it impossible to determine the true cost.

One cannot ignore the fact that this occurred on the watch of the Justin Trudeau government, raising questions about leadership and competence. The urgency created by COVID-19 is not an excuse for the management lapses that allowed ArriveCan’s development expenses to spiral out of control. More than a year passed without the Public Health Agency of Canada or the CBSA taking charge of the project, leading to a confusing array of contractors and subcontractors, and non-competitive contracts awarded without clear directions or proper documentation.

The spotlight is on a two-person Ottawa tech firm, GC Strategies, which received the initial ArriveCan contract worth $2.4 million, eventually netting $19.1 million. The subsequent replacement of three contracts with a single $25 million contract, awarded without competition, raises serious concerns about the procurement process.

Analysis: ArriveCan is a mess — but the scandal hides some bigger questions

February 6, 2021

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s response, stating that it’s “obvious” that contracting rules weren’t followed, highlights a fundamental problem in the execution of projects. Even in difficult times, rules must be followed, and accountability is paramount. The ArriveCan debacle is a stark reminder that, in the pursuit of urgency, basic management and contracting practices should never be ignored.

The ArriveCan scandal echoes broader questions about how the federal government operates. The reliance on external contractors and a lack of internal capabilities have been persistent issues, leading to costly and inefficient projects. It’s a pattern that needs to be addressed to ensure taxpayer dollars are spent wisely.

September 26, 2022

While the Trudeau government faces criticism from opposition leaders like Pierre Poilievre, it’s crucial to move beyond political blame games and focus on reforming the system. The call to cut back on outside consultants and invest in building internal capabilities is a step in the right direction.

As we dissect the ArriveCan mess, we must not lose sight of the bigger picture – the need for a more accountable, transparent, and efficient government. The ArriveCan debacle should serve as a catalyst for positive change, prompting a thorough examination of how our public service functions and what steps can be taken to ensure better governance in the future. (AI)