2024-06 – mackaycartoons

Tuesday March 26, 2024

March 26, 2024 by Graeme MacKay

March 26, 2024

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Tuesday March 26, 2024

Upholding Democracy: The Urgent Need to Combat Extremism and Misinformation

August 7, 2020

In recent years, we’ve witnessed a troubling trend that threatens the very foundation of our democracy: the rise of extremism and misinformation in politics. From baseless conspiracy theories to targeted threats against politicians, these toxic forces are corroding public trust, undermining the integrity of elections, and eroding the principles of democracy.

As citizens, we must not turn a blind eye to this growing menace. It’s imperative that authorities, from government agencies to law enforcement, recognize the gravity of the situation and take decisive action to address it. The consequences of inaction are too dire to ignore.

First and foremost, the safety and security of our elected officials must be paramount. The alarming normalization of threats against politicians, fueled by extremist narratives and personal grievances, poses a clear and present danger to those who serve our country. Every threat, no matter how seemingly insignificant, must be taken seriously, investigated thoroughly, and met with swift and decisive action.

News: Anti-authority narratives could tear ‘fabric of society,’ intelligence report warns

September 13, 2023

Moreover, we cannot afford to underestimate the impact of misinformation on the electoral process. Falsehoods spread rapidly in the digital age, reaching millions of unsuspecting citizens and distorting their perceptions of reality. From foreign interference to domestic disinformation campaigns, the threats to the integrity of our elections are manifold and must be met with robust countermeasures.

It’s incumbent upon authorities to bolster efforts to combat extremism and misinformation at every level. This includes enhancing cybersecurity measures to safeguard our electoral infrastructure, cracking down on online platforms that amplify extremist rhetoric, and investing in education and media literacy initiatives to empower citizens to discern fact from fiction.

June 26, 2019

Furthermore, we must confront the root causes of extremism and address the grievances that fuel its growth. Economic inequality, social polarization, and political disenfranchisement all contribute to the fertile ground in which extremist ideologies take root. By addressing these underlying issues and fostering inclusive dialogue, we can build a more resilient society resistant to the siren call of extremism.

Inaction is not an option. The threats posed by extremism and misinformation are existential, and they require a concerted and coordinated response from all stakeholders. Our democracy hangs in the balance, and the time to act is now.

As citizens, we must demand accountability from our elected leaders and hold them to the highest standards of integrity and transparency. We must reject the politics of division and embrace a vision of unity and solidarity. Only then can we safeguard the future of our democracy for generations to come. (AI)

Saturday March 23, 2024

March 23, 2024 by Graeme MacKay

March 23, 2024

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Saturday March 23, 2024

Doug Ford’s Misguided Crusade Against Four-plexes

February 22, 2024

In the realm of housing policy, Ontario Premier Doug Ford has positioned himself as a knight in shining armour, valiantly defending the sanctity of single dwellings against the perceived onslaught of four-plexes. However, this gallant facade crumbles upon closer inspection, revealing a shortsighted approach that threatens to exacerbate the very housing issues he claims to champion.

Ford’s staunch opposition to four-plexes reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of the complex challenges facing Ontario’s housing market. By clinging to outdated notions of urban development, he perpetuates a narrative that pits single-family homes against denser housing options, failing to recognize the symbiotic relationship between the two.

News: Premier Ford says it’s a ‘massive mistake’ to impose four-plexes across Ontario

October 31, 2023

At the heart of Ford’s aversion to four-plexes lies a fear of community backlash and a misguided belief that denser housing will inevitably lead to chaos and discontent. Yet, this fear is unfounded, as numerous cities around the world have successfully integrated four-plexes and similar housing solutions into their neighborhoods, enriching communities and increasing affordability in the process.

May 12, 2023

Moreover, Ford’s refusal to embrace four-plexes ignores the pressing need for more diverse housing options in Ontario. With housing affordability reaching crisis levels and many residents priced out of the market, it is imperative that policymakers prioritize solutions that expand access to affordable housing for all Ontarians. Four-plexes offer a practical and scalable solution to this pressing issue, providing an opportunity to increase housing supply while simultaneously fostering vibrant and inclusive communities.

By turning a blind eye to the potential benefits of four-plexes, Ford not only fails to address the root causes of Ontario’s housing crisis but also perpetuates a system that prioritizes the interests of a select few over the well-being of the broader population. His refusal to adapt to changing demographics and housing needs speaks volumes about his commitment to serving the people of Ontario.

Opinion: Doug Ford hates urban density. That’s not the only reason I love it

November 23, 2022

Doug Ford’s crusade against four-plexes is a misguided endeavour that undermines efforts to address Ontario’s housing affordability crisis. Rather than clinging to outdated ideologies, Ford must embrace innovative solutions that expand access to affordable housing and foster sustainable, inclusive communities. It’s time for Ford to lay down his lance and recognize that in the battle for affordable housing, four-plexes are not the enemy, but rather a crucial ally in securing a brighter future for all Ontarians. (AI)

From sketch to finish, see the current way Graeme completes an editorial cartoon using an iPencil, the Procreate app, and a couple of cheats on an iPad Pro. If you’re creative, give illustration a try:

Friday March 22, 2024

March 22, 2024 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Friday March 22, 2024

Bonnie Crombie’s Flute Solo: A Discordant Note in the Symphony of Climate Action

March 14, 2024

In the ongoing symphony of global efforts to combat climate change, every leader must choose their instrument wisely. However, Bonnie Crombie, leader of the Ontario Liberal Party, seems to have selected a flute tuned to the dissonant chords of climate skepticism and political expediency. Her recent performance resembles less of a clarion call for urgent climate action and more of a discordant solo pandering to the whims of climate deniers, echoing the tunes played by her Conservative counterpart, Pierre Poilievre.

News: Bonnie Crombie rules out provincial carbon tax as part of Ontario Liberals’ 2026 election platform

December 5, 2023

Crombie’s decision to rule out a provincial carbon tax and her attempts to woo climate skeptics through her flute solo are not just off-key; they’re detrimental to the urgent cause of climate action. While the world’s scientists and leaders harmonize in their calls for bold measures to curb greenhouse gas emissions, Crombie’s flute solo strikes a jarring note, pandering to those who seek to delay or deny the reality of the climate crisis.

By sidestepping meaningful climate policy in favour of a performance aimed at appeasing climate deniers, Crombie not only fails to hit the right notes but risks drowning out the urgent calls for action. In a time when swift and decisive measures are needed to avert the worst impacts of climate change, Crombie’s flute solo falls short of the mark.

Analysis: The carbon tax has its critics — do any of them have better ideas?

September 9, 2023

Moreover, Crombie’s decision to prioritize political expediency over principled leadership raises concerns about her commitment to tackling the climate crisis head-on. While her flute solo may garner applause from a select audience, it does little to advance the cause of climate action or inspire confidence in her leadership.

In contrast to Crombie’s faltering performance, leaders around the world are orchestrating ambitious plans to transition to clean energy and reduce emissions. Crombie’s flute solo not only fails to contribute to this global effort but risks leaving Ontario out of tune with the rest of the world.

As the curtain rises on the defining challenge of our time, we cannot afford to be distracted by discordant solos or political posturing. Ontario deserves leaders who are willing to lead with conviction and courage, not pander to the doubts of the past. It’s time for Bonnie Crombie to set aside her flute and join the chorus of voices calling for urgent and decisive action on climate change. The orchestra is waiting, and the future of our planet hangs in the balance. (AI)

Thursday March 20, 2024

March 21, 2024 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Thursday March 20, 2024

Canada Must Prioritize Defending Ukraine and Supporting Palestine: A Call to Action

January 31, 2024

In recent months, the world has witnessed two crises of immense proportions: the relentless assault on Ukraine by Vladimir Putin’s Russia and the unfolding humanitarian catastrophe facing Palestinians in Gaza. As Canada grapples with its role in addressing these urgent challenges, it is imperative that we reassess our priorities and shift resources towards resisting Putin’s aggression while offering much-needed aid and support to Palestine.

News: Trudeau government to stop sending arms to Israel once details are worked out, Foreign Affairs Minister Mélanie Joly says

February 16, 2026

The decision by the Trudeau government to cease arms exports to Israel represents a step in the right direction. It acknowledges the need to reassess our relationship with countries engaged in conflicts that perpetuate human suffering. However, as we take this crucial step, we must also recognize the pressing need to confront the brutal actions of Putin’s regime in Ukraine.

The conflict in Ukraine has reached a critical juncture, with reports indicating that Ukrainian forces are facing catastrophic shortages of ammunition and air defences. As Putin continues his ruthless campaign to expand Russia’s borders, it is incumbent upon Canada to stand in solidarity with the Ukrainian people and provide the support they need to defend their sovereignty and territorial integrity.

News: US estimates Ukraine military shortages could grow catastrophic by late March

This support must go beyond mere words of condemnation. Canada has a moral obligation to act decisively in defence of democracy and freedom in Ukraine. This means redirecting resources previously allocated for arms sales to Israel towards bolstering Ukraine’s defence capabilities. It means providing military aid, training, and logistical support to ensure that Ukrainian forces have the tools they need to resist Putin’s aggression.

December 14, 2023

At the same time, Canada cannot turn a blind eye to the dire humanitarian situation facing Palestinians in Gaza. The recent escalation of violence has only exacerbated an already dire situation, with reports of widespread famine and suffering among the civilian population. As a nation committed to upholding human rights and dignity, Canada must step up its efforts to provide humanitarian aid and support to the people of Palestine.

This does not mean neglecting Ukraine or prioritizing one crisis over another. Rather, it requires a nuanced and balanced approach that recognizes the interconnectedness of these crises and the need for Canada to play a proactive role in addressing them both.

December 20, 2023

By shifting resources towards resisting Putin’s aggression in Ukraine while offering food, aid, and support to Palestine, Canada can demonstrate its commitment to upholding human rights, promoting peace, and confronting tyranny wherever it may arise. Now is the time for Canada to take bold and decisive action in defence of freedom and justice around the world. The Ukrainian people and the Palestinians are counting on us.

The Vital Role of Satire in Upholding Democratic Values

In response to the recent demand for an apology by HonestReporting Canada regarding the above editorial cartoon published by The Hamilton Spectator and The Waterloo Record, it is crucial to address the misconceptions and unfounded accusations put forth by the complainant.

The letters to the editor published in The Hamilton Spectator were inspired by a very active lobby group that advocates on behalf of Israel’s government. It’s evident from the letter writers’ addresses, Scarborough, Montreal, and Toronto that these are not usual readers of this newspaper. Instead of working to point out true acts of intolerance, orchestrated pile ons such as these are aimed to gaslight editorial cartoonists and columnists into submission, to self-censor, and to stifle opinion.

Firstly, the demand for an apology stems from a gross misinterpretation of the purpose and nature of editorial cartoons. These cartoons serve as a form of satire, a fundamental aspect of free expression in democratic societies. Satire often employs exaggeration and caricature to highlight social and political issues, including the actions of political leaders and governments. It is not meant to be taken literally, but rather as a means of commentary and critique.

My editorial cartoon in question, depicts Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Russian President Vladimir Putin engaged in military actions, juxtaposed with Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s announcement that Canada was halting arms sales to Israel. My mission as an editorial cartoonist includes observing Canada’s place in global affairs, and last week’s vote by Parliament to suspend arms shipments to the Netanyahu government was significant and warranted reaction. While the cartoon may appear provocative to some, its intention is clear: to comment on current events and political decisions in a satirical manner.

By Serge Chapleau. The true outrage is how veteran cartoonists get away with appropriating photographs in editorial cartoons. That needs to stop! Scroll down more about this cartoon below.

Furthermore, it is essential to recognize the pattern of silencing criticism of Netanyahu and the Israeli government by groups like HonestReporting Canada. Any form of dissent or critique is often met with accusations of antisemitism or defamation, effectively stifling open dialogue and debate. It is not the first time my cartoons have been baselessly targeted for being anti-Israel, or antisemitic. This tactic not only undermines the principles of free speech but also shields those in power from accountability and scrutiny.

The assertion that the cartoon constitutes antisemitism or promotes falsehoods about Israel’s actions is unsubstantiated and misleading. Criticizing the policies of a government, including Israel’s, does not equate to antisemitism. It is essential to differentiate between legitimate criticism of government actions and bigotry towards a particular group of people. One can can stand on humanitarian grounds demanding Hamas release the Israeli hostages, while at the same time demand the end of senseless killing of innocent Palestinian lives.

The complaint article also attempts to downplay the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and the disproportionate impact of the conflict on Palestinian civilians. It is crucial to acknowledge the complexities of the situation, including the role of Hamas, a designated terrorist organization, in perpetuating violence and exploiting the suffering of civilians for political gain. Ignoring these realities only serves to undermine efforts towards a peaceful resolution and perpetuates misinformation.

Finally, satirical portrayals of Justin Trudeau or Pierre Poilievre are not anti-Canada, nor is a lampoon of Joe Biden or Donald Trump, anti-American. An editorial cartoon that ridicules a leader of Israel is not anti-Israel commentary.

January 27, 2024 – Spiked due to self censorship

The demand for an apology from The Hamilton Spectator and The Waterloo Record is baseless and undermines the principles of free expression and critical discourse essential to a democratic society. Editorial cartoons play a vital role in fostering public debate and holding power to account, and attempts to censor or silence them must be vehemently opposed.

HonestReporting Canada should redirect its efforts towards more constructive dialogue by effectively addressing instances of antisemitism where they genuinely exist, rather than attempting to silence editorial cartoonists where no antisemitism is present. By promoting understanding and tolerance rather than resorting to censorship and division, HonestReporting Canada can play a more meaningful role in fostering productive discourse and advancing genuine efforts towards peace and mutual respect. – Graeme MacKay

Letter to the Editor, The Waterloo Record, Saturday March 23, 2024

Cartoon missed the mark

I must protest the horrible cartoon you published on Thursday’s Opinion page, which totally misrepresents the truth in Gaza and Israel.

War is always ugly and terrible, but let’s get the facts straight! And stop these malignant caricatures!

I hope I will see an apology very soon.

Yosef Abramczyk, Montreal

Promote messages of tolerance – Letter to the Editor, The Hamilton Spectator, Monday March 25, 2024

For our community, the recent cancellation of the Hamilton Jewish Film Festival at the Playhouse Cinema echoed a distressing past reminiscent of Kristallnacht, which marked the start of widespread boycotts against Jews. Within this environment, I was filled with despair by the recent anti-Israel political cartoon of Graeme MacKay, published in The Hamilton Spectator. The abhorrent image stirred the memories of blood libels and was reminiscent of the antisemitic propaganda of Der Stürmer.

During these difficult times, when antisemitism is rearing its ugly and pernicious head, our community is in dire need of responsible leadership and a media presence that does not perpetuate antisemitic tropes. Our local media has a responsibility to foster coexistence rather than echoing the darkest chapters of history.

The Hamilton Spectator must take a stand against such narratives and promote a message of tolerance and inclusivity. It is crucial, now more than ever, that we learn from the past and commit to a future where all members of our community feel safe, respected and valued.

Daniel Green, rabbi of Adas Israel Congregation

Appalled and dismayed– Letter to the Editor, The Hamilton Spectator, Monday March 25, 2024

I am appalled and dismayed at your having decided to include in your March 21 publication the disgusting and misinformed cartoon produced by Graeme MacKay which equates the wars in Gaza and Ukraine and which depicts Israel as deliberately targeting innocent civilians and as being the main cause of Palestinian hunger and suffering.

Jeffrey Sugar, Scarborough

Shocked to see cartoon – Letter to the Editor, The Hamilton Spectator, Monday March 25, 2024

We are shocked that you would allow such an antisemitic cartoon in our paper in our city that has a large Jewish population. We trust you will apologize and not be so one-sided and research the truth of the conflict.

Bill and Judi Moffat, Burlington

Cartoon was shameful – Letter to the Editor, The Hamilton Spectator, Monday March 25, 2024

I must protest the cartoon you published, which totally misrepresents the truth in Gaza and Israel in a horrible, horrible way. Shame on you! Shame on the cartoonist! It’s not for me to demand any apology, but if you have any decency, I hope you will apologize.

Yosef Abramczyk, Montreal

Cartoon was offensive – Letter to the Editor, The Hamilton Spectator, Monday March 25, 2024

How could you publish an editorial cartoon depicting Israel as committing state-sponsored terrorism against innocent Palestinian civilians? Factually wrong and offensive.

Esther M. Cantor, Toronto

Serge Chapleau’s recent cartoon depicting Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as a vampire has sparked heated controversy, with accusations of antisemitism echoing through the halls of public discourse. However, amidst the uproar, it’s crucial to recognize the vital role of political satire in challenging power structures and fostering critical dialogue.

At its core, Chapleau’s cartoon is a scathing commentary on Netanyahu’s leadership and policies, particularly in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. By portraying Netanyahu as a vampire, Chapleau cleverly taps into the symbolism of vampirism, depicting a figure who metaphorically drains resources and perpetuates conflict. This metaphorical portrayal is a hallmark of political satire, aiming to provoke thought and discussion rather than perpetuate hate.

Critics argue that the vampire imagery evokes antisemitic tropes, drawing parallels to historical propaganda. However, it’s essential to distinguish between legitimate criticism of a political figure and bigotry. Chapleau’s cartoon does not target Netanyahu or Jewish people as a whole based on their ethnicity or religion. Instead, it targets Netanyahu’s actions and policies as a public figure, which are subject to scrutiny and critique like any other leader.

Furthermore, the Association of Canadian Cartoonists rightly points out that caricaturing world leaders is a common practice, and Netanyahu should not be exempt from such scrutiny. Satire serves as a check on power, holding leaders accountable for their decisions and behaviours. In this light, Chapleau’s cartoon is a bold assertion of free speech and artistic expression, essential pillars of democratic societies.

Someone who gets satire!

Moreover, the notion that Chapleau’s cartoon is inherently antisemitic ignores the nuanced context in which it was created. Chapleau himself has stated that he did not intend any antisemitic connotations with his cartoon. Instead, he aimed to use striking imagery to make a powerful statement about Netanyahu’s leadership. As such, accusations of antisemitism risk diluting the significance of genuine instances of bigotry and discrimination.

While Chapleau’s cartoon may be provocative and controversial, it serves a vital purpose in challenging authority and fostering public debate. Rather than stifling dissent, we should embrace satire as a tool for social commentary and reflection. By engaging with Chapleau’s cartoon in a thoughtful and critical manner, we can move beyond knee-jerk reactions and confront the complex issues it raises with nuance and empathy. (Graeme MacKay)

On April 6, 2024 an opinion piece by yours truly, Graeme MacKay, was printed in the Hamilton Spectator in answer to the fallout from this editorial cartoon.

Wednesday March 20, 2024

March 20, 2024 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Wednesday March 20, 2024

The West’s Dangerous Slumber: Apathy and Diminishing Resolve in the Face of Authoritarian Expansionism

February 22, 2024

As the world grapples with the ominous spectre of authoritarian expansionism, the West’s response is marked by a dangerous combination of apathy and diminishing resolve. From the halls of power in Washington to the streets of European capitals, the signs of complacency are unmistakable, and the consequences could not be more dire.

The recent editorial in the Toronto Star, alongside reports of Vladimir Putin’s orchestrated victory in the Russian elections, paints a stark picture of the challenges we face. However, amidst this turmoil, there’s a troubling trend emerging from Canada – a nation known for its commitment to democracy and human rights.

News: Putin claims landslide in Russian election and scorns US democracy

June 6, 2023

While Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s government has shown steadfast support for Ukraine, signs of Ukrainian “fatigue” among certain factions in Canada’s political landscape are becoming increasingly apparent. The editorial’s mention of Conservative voters questioning the level of aid to Ukraine speaks volumes about the erosion of resolve within Canadian society.

But the issue extends far beyond Canadian borders. The growing indifference in the United States, particularly among certain political factions, is equally alarming. The editorial’s condemnation of the Republican-led U.S. Congress for turning its back on Kyiv in the face of Russian aggression underscores the depth of this problem.

The Trump-era “America First” rhetoric, coupled with a reluctance to engage meaningfully on the world stage, has created a vacuum that authoritarian leaders like Putin are all too eager to fill. The stalled aid package in the U.S. House of Representatives, tied to unrelated domestic issues, is a glaring example of how short-term political interests can undermine global stability and security.

This trend is not only concerning in its own right but also plays directly into the hands of authoritarian leaders like Putin. A divided West, lacking the unity and determination to confront aggression abroad, only emboldens those who seek to undermine the principles of democracy and freedom.

Editorial: We will be judged if we turn our backs on Ukraine now

May 3, 2022

The headline “The West’s Dangerous Slumber” encapsulates this perilous situation perfectly. It serves as a wake-up call to all who value liberty and democracy, urging them to recognize the signs of authoritarian expansionism and take decisive action before it’s too late.

In the face of adversity, we cannot afford to succumb to apathy or complacency. The time to stand up for our values and defend the vulnerable is now. The fate of Ukraine, the future of democracy, and the stability of the world hang in the balance. Let history remember us not for our indifference but for our unwavering commitment to justice and freedom. (AI)

By Ivan Glassco, The Hamilton Spectator, March 21, 1936

The above cartoon is a parody of one original drawn by The Hamilton Spectator’s Editorial Cartoonist at the time it was published, for March 21, 1936. A braided German girl symbolizing the “Rhine” fitting herself into a dress of armour labelled “Hitler Gowns.” The upper caption reads, “The new dress.” This suggests the militarization and fortification of the Rhine region under Adolf Hitler’s regime, symbolized by the dress of armour. The imagery implies the incorporation of the Rhine, a historically significant river in Germany, into Hitler’s aggressive policies and military expansion. The term “Hitler Gowns” may be used sarcastically to highlight the oppression. Ivan Russell Glassco, was born in Hamilton, Ontario, in 1902. Professionally, he transitioned from architecture, gained recognition for realistic caricatures, and became the editorial cartoonist for the Hamilton Spectator in 1934, before his death in 1941 while training with the Royal Canadian Air Force.