Friday May 30 2025
Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Friday May 30 2025
Published in the Toronto Star.
Canada’s Sovereignty is Not for Sale: Rejecting Trump’s 51st State Rhetoric
April 30, 2025
In the latest saga of U.S.-Canada relations, President Donald Trump’s proposal for Canada to join the Golden Dome missile defence system has rekindled an age-old narrative that Canada could become the 51st state of the United States. This rhetoric, used as a bargaining chip to pressure Canada into a costly defence scheme, is not only disrespectful but fundamentally undermines the sovereignty of our nation.
Trump’s proposition—demanding that Canada pay a hefty US$61 billion for participation in the Golden Dome unless we concede to annexation—has been aptly described by Canadian UN Ambassador Bob Rae as akin to a “protection racket.” This comparison highlights the absurdity of the offer: pay an exorbitant fee for defence collaboration or lose our national identity. Such a proposal is not only offensive but also dismissive of Canada’s autonomy and history as a sovereign nation.
April 2, 2025
Prime Minister Mark Carney’s refusal to engage in public negotiations over this matter is a wise move, emphasizing that Canada is “not for sale” and “won’t be for sale, ever.” The rhetoric of annexation not only echoes historical overreach but also disregards the reality of Canada as a proud, independent country.
As the world faces escalating global threats, Canada recognizes the need to bolster its defence capabilities. The government has already committed to increasing defence spending, aiming to reach NATO’s target of 2% of GDP by 2030. However, the beneficiaries of this defence investment are shifting. Canada is looking eastward, toward Europe, rather than southward to the U.S., as it considers joining the ReArm Europe initiative. This strategic pivot is not merely a snub to the U.S. military-industrial complex; it is a calculated decision to diversify our defence partnerships and strengthen our domestic military industry.
ReArm Europe offers Canada the opportunity to collaborate with European allies, buying military equipment at competitive prices and providing a new market for Canadian defence products. This move allows Canada to reduce its reliance on the United States, which currently receives 75% of our defence procurement spending. By investing in non-traditional partners, Canada is not only enhancing its military capabilities but also asserting its economic independence and strategic autonomy.
April 23, 2025
Moreover, public sentiment reflects a growing disillusionment with Trump’s tactics. Many Canadians, as seen in reader comments, are frustrated with the idea of being coerced into a defence arrangement under the guise of annexation or economic pressure. The rhetoric of becoming a 51st state is not only unrealistic but also dismissive of Canada’s rich heritage and commitment to sovereign equality, principles enshrined in the United Nations Charter.
Canada’s path forward involves strengthening our defence through diversified partnerships and robust domestic investment. While we recognize the importance of collaboration with allies, it must be on terms that respect our sovereignty and strategic interests. Trump’s rhetoric is a reminder of the necessity to stand firm in our national identity and reject any proposals that compromise our independence. Canada’s future will be defined by partnerships that respect mutual interests, not by yielding to outdated and disrespectful notions of annexation.
Canada’s Defence Awakening: Beyond the Umbrella – Friday May 30, 2025
Posted to Substack
These are indeed interesting times for Canada, as the nation begins to recognize the importance of strengthening its defence capabilities. This was a central promise made to voters when they entrusted the newly led Liberal party with governance. Amidst the tense dynamics between Canada and the U.S., Trump’s questioning of Canadian sovereignty has unexpectedly served as a catalyst. It has prompted Canada to take its defence more seriously, encouraging us to step out from under the U.S. security umbrella and arm ourselves independently. Canadians seem to have accepted this reality, understanding that while we bolster our defences, there might be sacrifices in social spending elsewhere—but that’s a topic for another cartoon.
Friday March 1, 2024 – More than a year ago, Canada’s Liberal government had not prioritized defence spending, focusing on its political standing during declining popularity, but escalating global tensions have since pressured Canada to balance domestic social investments with meeting NATO commitments.
In today’s cartoon, the scene unfolds at an arms Expo. On one side, European vendors display traditional military gear—jets, tanks, missiles—all in the familiar army green. On the opposite side, Trump’s “Golden Dome” gleams ostentatiously, with a sign that reads, “Just $61B or Become a State and It’s FREE*,” complete with a cheeky nod to terms and conditions. The humour lies in the absurdity of Trump’s offer and the fanciful price tag seemingly pulled from his bum.
Wednesday, October 13, 2010 – After Canada lost its bid for a UN Security Council seat to Portugal, the Conservative government blamed Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff for undermining their campaign, while Ignatieff criticized the government’s foreign policy, calling the loss a “sad day” and dismissing their blame as “ridiculous.”
What brings satisfaction is seeing Mark Carney adeptly handle this situation. Unlike his predecessor, he confidently asserts that Canada’s sovereignty empowers us to seek partnerships beyond the U.S., enhancing our defence strategy with new allies. The longstanding post-war security guarantee from the U.S. is essentially over, and while this means Canada is cut loose, it also liberates us from over-reliance on the U.S. military-industrial complex. This shift allows Canada to forge its own path in defence, enriched by diverse collaborations.
