Alberta – mackaycartoons

Tuesday April 8, 2025

April 8, 2025 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Tuesday April 8, 2025

A Call for Unity Amidst Division

March 25, 2025

In recent weeks, the political landscape in Canada has been marked by a troubling resurgence of separatist rhetoric emanating from Western Canada, particularly from figures like Preston Manning. His desperate warning that a victory for Mark Carney’s Liberals would lead to the breakup of Canada is not only alarmist but also counterproductive. It threatens to exacerbate divisions at a time when national unity is more critical than ever.

Opinion: Mark Carney poses a threat to national unity

Manning’s perspective, which positions Western separation as a legitimate response to perceived grievances, fails to recognize the complex realities faced by all Canadians. While it is essential to acknowledge the frustrations of those in Alberta and Saskatchewan—regions that have long felt overlooked by federal policies—resorting to threats of secession is not a constructive solution. Such extreme viewpoints only serve to polarize discussions and undermine the collaborative spirit necessary for addressing shared challenges.

December 2, 2022

However, dismissing Manning’s concerns outright ignores a significant truth: the fossil fuel sector in Western Canada is not just an economic powerhouse; it is a lifeline for many communities. The realities of shifting global energy dynamics and the impacts of U.S. President Donald Trump’s reckless economic policies have created uncertainty that can no longer be overlooked. The tariffs and trade tensions he has instigated have put pressure on Canadian industries, particularly those heavily reliant on fossil fuels.

As we navigate these turbulent waters, it is crucial to strike a balance between addressing environmental imperatives and safeguarding the livelihoods of those dependent on fossil fuel industries. The call for an immediate end to fossil fuel reliance without a viable transition plan risks not only economic devastation but also the loss of social cohesion in communities that have built their identities around these sectors.

Opinion: A look at the growing discord in Western Canada

September 1, 2021

Danielle Smith’s alignment with Trump and her provocative stance on Alberta’s autonomy further complicate this already fraught landscape. While she champions the voices of those who feel marginalized, her approach often mirrors the divisive rhetoric that only deepens the chasm between regions. It is essential to understand that unity cannot be built on fear or threats; rather, it requires dialogue, compromise, and a commitment to finding common ground.

What is needed now is a comprehensive and inclusive discussion that brings together various stakeholders—politicians, industry leaders, environmental advocates, and community members—to explore pathways toward a sustainable energy future that respects the economic realities of Western Canada. This means investing in green technology and transition strategies that not only address climate change but also provide new opportunities for workers in the fossil fuel sector.

In the face of daunting challenges posed by external forces, Canada must remain steadfast in its commitment to unity. We cannot allow the desperate warnings of figures like Manning to derail the essential conversations about how to move forward together. Instead, let us focus on building a resilient nation that acknowledges regional concerns while striving for a sustainable and inclusive future.

News: Poilievre distances himself from ex-Reform Leader Preston Manning’s comments on Western separatism

October 12, 2019

The road ahead may be rocky, but by fostering understanding and collaboration, Canada can navigate these rough seas and emerge stronger, united in our diversity and shared purpose. It is time to reject divisive rhetoric and work collectively toward a future that honours both our environmental responsibilities and our economic realities.

Looking For a Strong Manning-Date

As someone who closely follows elections, I’ve always found polls to be incredibly useful in gauging the political climate and predicting election outcomes. Over the past two elections, I’ve made it a point to draw on polls at least once in editorial during each campaign. It’s fascinating to look back and see how the parties were faring just weeks before election day.

During Justin Trudeau’s tenure, the polls often depicted a flatline between the two main parties, leading to somewhat predictable outcomes and the formation of minority governments. This trend seemed to reflect a broader lack of trust and confidence among Canadians towards both the Liberals and Conservatives. Consequently, we’ve experienced years of weak governance, with Trudeau’s position becoming increasingly fragile with each passing election since 2015.

The polls have not been kind to the Liberals under Trudeau in recent years, while the Conservatives, under Pierre Poilievre, have seen astronomical support. However, there’s an old saying about peaking too early, and that seems to be the case for Poilievre. The pendulum of political favour has swung, but rather than benefiting the Conservatives, it appears to have favoured centrists, especially with Mark Carney now leading the Liberal Party.

If there ever was a need for renewed confidence and unity, it is now, especially at a time when global security and economic order are being shaken. A majority government is needed, and the right person to head it is the reasonable, calm, and somewhat boring father figure, Mark Carney. He stands in contrast to Pierre Poilievre, who, with his petulant and angry demeanour, is neither a centrist nor a uniter.

While I sympathize with Conservatives who express frustration with the Liberals, it’s clear that the pendulum has indeed swung toward a more centrist approach. Carney’s leadership offers a new perspective and potential for renewed confidence among Canadians. As we approach the next election, it will be interesting to see how these dynamics play out and what the polls will reveal in the final stretch.

Check out my making-of animated editorial cartoon for April 7, 2025, below! If you haven’t yet, please subscribe to my Substack newsletter, where I share weekly editorial cartoons every Saturday morning. Substack is a crucial platform for me amidst the uncertainties of being a staff cartoonist, especially given recent layoffs and newspaper closures affecting our field. As long as I hold my position, subscriptions will remain free. Thank you for your support! This “note” helps craft my weekly posts and showcases animated versions of my cartoons. Enjoy!

– The Graeme Gallery

Read on Substack

Friday January 17, 2025

January 17, 2025 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Friday January 17, 2025, and The Toronto Star

Balancing Provinces and Prioritizing Canada: A Call for Unity

December 18, 2024

In the complex landscape of international trade and economic diplomacy, Canada’s provincial leaders are faced with the challenge of balancing regional interests with national priorities. The recent discussions around potential tariffs from the incoming U.S. administration have underscored the necessity for a unified Canadian front. However, Alberta’s Premier Danielle Smith’s divergent stance has sparked a debate that goes beyond provincial borders, touching on the very essence of Canadian unity and national strategy.

Alberta’s economic landscape is undeniably tied to its oil industry, a sector that has been a cornerstone of the province’s prosperity and a significant contributor to the national economy. The oil sands have not only fuelled Alberta’s growth but have also been a lifeline for Canada, providing jobs, energy security, and substantial revenues. For Premier Smith, prioritizing Alberta’s interests is not only a political necessity but also a reflection of her commitment to her constituents who depend on this vital industry.

News: Premiers talk tactics for a game of tariff chicken

December 3, 2024

Yet, as Ontario’s Premier Doug Ford aptly put it, “Our country comes first.” In times of external threats, such as the looming tariffs that could destabilize the Canadian economy, unity becomes paramount. The strength of a nation lies in its ability to stand together, to prioritize collective well-being over regional gains. This is where the balance must be struck—between advocating for provincial interests and aligning with a national strategy that safeguards all Canadians.

Smith’s decision to distance herself from the consensus reached by her fellow premiers raises questions about the broader implications of her stance. While her focus on Alberta’s oil industry is understandable, her approach risks isolating the province at a time when cohesion is crucial. By not joining the collective effort, Alberta may inadvertently weaken its negotiating power, as well as that of the entire country.

Doug Ford’s leadership in rallying the premiers reflects a commitment to presenting a united front, essential in negotiations with a complex and unpredictable U.S. administration. His message is clear: while every province has its unique needs and priorities, these should not overshadow the importance of national unity. A fragmented approach only serves to undermine Canada’s position on the global stage and risks playing into the hands of those who might benefit from division.

Opinion: Alberta’s premier is playing right into Donald Trump’s hands

February 7, 2023

In this context, it is imperative for Premier Smith to reconsider her strategy. By aligning more closely with her fellow premiers, she can advocate effectively for Alberta while contributing to a stronger, more cohesive national strategy. This does not mean abandoning Alberta’s interests but rather integrating them into a broader Canadian framework that seeks to protect the entire nation’s economic future.

The path forward requires collaboration, dialogue, and a willingness to put Canada’s collective interests at the forefront. As the country navigates these uncertain times, all provinces, led by their premiers, must work together to ensure that Canada’s voice is unified and its position strengthened. Only then can we effectively safeguard our economy, our sovereignty, and our future in a rapidly changing global landscape.

The Premiers meeting this week was a real eye-opener, showing just how tricky it can be to balance provincial and federal interests. And right in the thick of it is Alberta’s Premier, Danielle Smith, who’s found herself in a bit of an awkward spot. Why, you ask? Well, aside from her odd chumminess with Donald Trump—seriously, a weekend jaunt to Mar-a-Lago and plans to attend his inauguration?—she’s been steering Alberta in a direction that’s causing some raised eyebrows.

Smith’s focus on protecting Alberta’s oil industry makes sense given its importance to the province’s economy. But here’s the rub: oil is a hot-button issue, especially as we push towards green energy. Meanwhile, Canada’s trying to juggle putting a price on carbon while still propping up the fossil fuel industry. It’s a bit of a head-scratcher, really—oil revenues are crucial not just for Alberta, but for the federal government too, providing jobs and fuelling budgets.

Then there’s Trump’s looming 25% tariffs, which could seriously mess with the Canadian economy. Right now, it’s all about playing the waiting game to see if these tariffs will hit us across the board, or if, fingers crossed, oil might get a pass given the U.S.’s reliance on it.

Now, here’s where it gets even more tangled. Ontario’s Premier, Doug Ford, is rallying for a united front against these tariffs, saying we should protect our own turf but always put Canada first. It’s a solid point, given that oil is our ace in the hole—a big bargaining chip in the face of Trump’s wild tariff plans. But Smith’s solo approach could undermine this strategy.

The way I see it, Alberta needs to think about joining forces with the other provinces. A united stance gives us a stronger hand to play on the world stage, ensuring we protect both provincial and national interests. By weaving Alberta’s oil concerns into a broader Canadian strategy, we can amplify our voice globally and maybe, just maybe, take some wind out of Trump’s tariff sails.

So, what’s next? It’s a delicate dance, this one. But one thing’s for sure: how Alberta chooses to move forward could tip the balance for all of Canada. Let’s hope they choose wisely. Things can get very ugly, indeed.

I tossed a question out to my social media followers, asking for their take on Ontario Premier Doug Ford’s advice to Alberta Premier Danielle Smith regarding the Trump tariffs: “…protect your jurisdiction but country comes first, Canada’s the priority.” The overwhelming sentiment leaned in favour of Ford, yet the responses shed light on a deeper divide. Many pointed out that Alberta has often found itself at odds with the rest of Canada, citing examples like stalled pipeline expansions and the Keystone XL debacle. Some argue Smith was elected to defend Alberta’s interests, especially when those interests seem sidelined by national strategies. Others highlighted Alberta’s role as a major contributor to federal transfer payments, questioning why it should shoulder the burden without due consideration. A sentiment echoed was Alberta feeling like the 51st state, as its interests are perceived to be overridden by Ontario’s convenience. Meanwhile, some viewed Ford’s comment as perhaps his smartest yet, though motives were questioned—is it genuine, or just a strategic move for votes? The debate underscores the complex dynamics of provincial versus national priorities in Canada, and how this tension plays into the broader tariff negotiations.

Enjoy the January 17, 2025 making-of animated editorial cartoon below. Please subscribe to my Substack newsletter, if you haven’t already. Posts come out every Friday or Saturday as I summarize the week that was in my editorial cartoons. What you’re reading now is regarded as a “note”, which is used to help compose my weekly posts and showcase the animated versions of my daily editorial cartoons.

– The Graeme Gallery

Read on Substack

Friday February 9, 2024

February 9, 2024 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Friday February 9, 2024

Pierre Poilievre’s Defence of Alberta’s Transgender Policies: A Dangerous Culture War at the Expense of Marginalized Youth

February 3, 2024

In recent days, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre has found himself at the centre of a contentious debate surrounding Alberta Premier Danielle Smith’s controversial transgender policies. Poilievre’s vocal support for Smith’s measures raises concerns about the Conservative Party’s priorities and its willingness to engage in a culture war that may have detrimental effects on a small, marginalized group – transgender youth.

Poilievre’s defence of Smith’s policies revolves around the idea that parents should have more say over their children’s lives, particularly when it comes to sensitive matters like gender identity. While advocating for parental involvement is not inherently problematic, Poilievre seems to be echoing Smith’s stance without critically examining the potential harm these policies could inflict on transgender youth.

The focus on parental consent for preferred names and pronouns in schools, as well as restrictions on medical interventions such as puberty blockers and hormone therapy, appears to be more about currying favour with a social conservative base than safeguarding the well-being of transgender individuals. By aligning himself with Smith’s controversial policies, Poilievre is punching down on a vulnerable and marginalized group, using them as pawns in a larger culture war.

News: Pierre Poilievre defends Alberta Premier Smith on transgender policies

May 26, 2023

One of the most alarming aspects of Smith’s proposals is the ban on “top” and “bottom” surgeries for minors aged 17 and under. This goes against established standards of care and seems to prioritize a rigid ideological stance over the well-being of transgender youth who may benefit from these medical interventions. Poilievre’s failure to critically assess these measures raises questions about his commitment to evidence-based policy and the rights of transgender individuals.

Additionally, Smith’s attempt to exclude trans women and girls from women’s sports under the guise of safety and fairness is a thinly veiled discriminatory measure. Poilievre’s endorsement of such policies further emphasizes the Conservative Party’s alignment with socially conservative groups rather than standing up for the rights of all Canadians.

News: Conservatives tell MPs not to comment on Alberta transgender policies, prioritize parental rights, internal e-mail shows

June 24, 2021

The condemnation of Smith’s policies by LGBTQ groups, trans advocates, and medical associations highlights the potential harm they could inflict on transgender youth. The Canadian Pediatric Society emphasizes the importance of gender-affirming medical interventions for some adolescents, citing lower odds of suicidal ideation associated with access to puberty blockers.

In contrast, Poilievre’s defense of these policies without addressing the concerns raised by experts and advocacy groups appears to be a calculated move to exploit a divisive issue for political gain. This approach not only disregards the well-being of transgender youth but also perpetuates a harmful narrative that can contribute to the stigmatization and marginalization of an already vulnerable community.

Pierre Poilievre’s support for Alberta Premier Danielle Smith’s transgender policies raises serious questions about the Conservative Party’s priorities and commitment to inclusivity. By aligning with divisive measures that target a small and marginalized group, Poilievre appears to be prioritizing political posturing over the well-being and rights of transgender youth, perpetuating a dangerous culture war at their expense. (AI)

Saturday February 3, 2024

February 3, 2024 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Saturday February 3, 2024

Alberta’s Urgent Issues Overshadowed by Premier Smith’s Controversial Policies

In the vast landscape of pressing challenges faced by Alberta, Premier Danielle Smith’s recent unveiling of sweeping changes to the province’s policies, particularly those related to transgender youth, has sparked a divisive debate. While the issue at hand deserves attention and discussion, it is crucial to recognize that this might be a calculated distraction from more critical and urgent issues that demand the government’s immediate focus.

December 2, 2022

Alberta is grappling with a multifaceted crisis that includes a strained healthcare system, an opioid epidemic, a severe shortage of doctors, and a growing crisis of homelessness and housing. These challenges directly impact the well-being of Albertans on a daily basis and require comprehensive and immediate solutions. Yet, Premier Smith’s policy changes, while significant, seem to divert attention from these urgent matters.

In shaping herself as the northern version of American anti-“woke” governors, such as Governor Ron DeSantis of Florida, Premier Smith appears to be strategically appealing to her far-right conservative base. By focusing on controversial issues related to gender identity and sports, she risks sidelining the broader concerns that affect the entire population.

News: Danielle Smith unveils sweeping changes to Alberta’s student gender identity, sports and surgery policies

October 14, 2022

The policies, as announced, have faced criticism for going further than those in other provinces like Saskatchewan and New Brunswick. Critics argue that these changes not only interfere ideologically in the provision of necessary healthcare for trans and gender-diverse young people but also pose a risk of forcing vulnerable individuals back into the closet or even homelessness.

While the transgender youth policy is indeed important, it must be viewed in the context of the more immediate crises confronting the province. The hospital emergency room crisis, exacerbated by the ongoing pandemic, demands urgent attention and resources to ensure the well-being of all Albertans. The opioid crisis continues to claim lives, necessitating a comprehensive strategy for addiction treatment and harm reduction.

Moreover, the severe shortage of doctors is a systemic issue that requires proactive measures to attract and retain healthcare professionals in the province. Addressing homelessness and the housing crisis is paramount to ensuring the basic dignity and security of Alberta’s citizens.

May 31, 2023

Groups supporting transgender rights, including Skipping Stone Foundation and Egale Canada, have condemned Smith’s policies, calling them a direct and unprecedented attack on 2SLGBTQI+ Canadians and trans and gender-diverse youth. Legal battles are looming, with promises to challenge the constitutionality of the measures in court.

Moreover, the proposed restrictions have drawn international concern, with Canada’s health minister labeling them “extremely dangerous.” The potential impact on children’s lives has sparked strong condemnations from Liberal ministers, emphasizing that issues surrounding kids’ reproductive health should not be turned into political stunts.

Doctors in the province have criticized Premier Smith for making medically “false” statements about transgender youth care and gender reassignment surgery. The lack of consultation with medical professionals raises questions about the evidence behind these policies and whether they are based on ideology rather than scientific literature.

News: Alberta premier’s policy changes around trans youth could be harmful: doctors

November 15, 2022

As Alberta’s healthcare professionals express concerns about the potential harm these policies may inflict on vulnerable youth, it becomes evident that the government should prioritize a broader and more inclusive dialogue. In a province facing numerous urgent crises, it is vital to ensure that policies are rooted in evidence, consultation, and a genuine commitment to the well-being of all citizens.

While the issue of transgender youth and related policies deserves thoughtful consideration, Premier Smith’s approach risks overshadowing the more immediate and critical challenges faced by the people of Alberta. It is time for a nuanced, evidence-based approach that addresses urgent issues without sacrificing the well-being of any segment of the population for political gain. (AI)

Thursday November 30, 2023

November 30, 2023 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Thursday November 30, 2023

Navigating Diplomacy at COP28: Guilbeault’s Uphill Battle

November 4, 2023

As the world anticipates the United Nations summit on climate change, the focus broadens beyond the global initiatives to combat environmental challenges, delving into the intricate dynamics of diplomacy within the conference halls. Canada’s Environment Minister, Steven Guilbeault, once a fervent advocate for climate action, now faces a unique challenge as he steps into the complex tapestry of COP28.

Guilbeault’s journey through COP28 takes an unexpected turn with the presence of Premier Danielle Smith and Premier Scott Moe of Alberta and Saskatchewan. Their approach to the conference diverges from the global narrative of reducing reliance on fossil fuels, appearing more inclined towards sustaining the fossil fuel industry in their provinces.

Analysis: Alberta could lead the energy transition. But Danielle Smith’s approach and Ottawa’s subsidies are a toxic combination

May 31, 2023

Premier Smith ardently champions Alberta’s “clean” fossil fuel industry, particularly emphasizing carbon capture and storage (CCS) as a solution to cut emissions. However, recent reports from the International Energy Agency cast doubt on the global efficacy of CCS, challenging its status as a transformative solution.

As Premier Smith confidently strides into COP28, accompanied by over a hundred Alberta delegates, the inherent conflict of interest becomes apparent. The conference, hosted by Sultan Ahmed Al Jaber, CEO of the UAE’s national oil company, ADNOC, and the UAE’s climate envoy, raises suspicions of a conflict of interest, especially with leaked documents indicating Al Jaber’s intention to broker oil and gas deals during the conference.

This sets the stage for an uncomfortable encounter between Smith and Guilbeault. Smith’s dismissal of Guilbeault as a “maverick” who “doesn’t seem to care about the Constitution” adds a layer of tension. While the federal government’s alignment with Alberta on promoting carbon capture and storage might offer a semblance of common ground, Smith’s move to invoke the sovereignty act against federal Clean Electricity Regulations hints at a deeper divide.

News: COP28: UAE planned to use climate talks to make oil deals

November 18, 2022

Guilbeault, tasked with advancing Canada’s commitment to fighting climate change, finds himself navigating a complex diplomatic landscape. As Premier Smith revels in her pro-oil-and-gas message, Guilbeault stands at the forefront, grappling with the clash between provincial and federal interests. It’s a delicate dance where finding common ground may prove elusive, especially considering the apparent disparity between the goals of the Prairie premiers and the broader global agenda for sustainability.

In this complex diplomatic ballet at COP28, Guilbeault represents the struggle to reconcile conflicting interests for the greater environmental good, a task that becomes even more challenging in the face of the unabashed promotion of fossil fuels under the guise of environmental responsibility by Prairie premiers.

The challenges at COP28 are not just about the global fight against climate change but also the nuanced struggles within the delegation halls. Steven Guilbeault finds himself at the heart of this intricate dance, striving to balance conflicting interests while championing the broader environmental agenda. (AI)