Bill C-5

Saturday June 28, 2025

Mark Carney's rapid passage of Bill C-5 contrasts with the criticism aimed at Doug Ford's Bill 5, highlighting differences in leadership styles and public perception.

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Saturday June 28, 2025

Carney’s Swift Bill C-5: A Canada Day Triumph Amid Ontario’s Criticism

The recent premiers' meeting in Saskatoon marks a hopeful shift in federal-provincial relations, with renewed collaboration and shared goals under Prime Minister Mark Carney.

June 4 2025

As Canada prepares to celebrate another Canada Day, Prime Minister Mark Carney has delivered on a promise that resonates deeply with the nation’s aspirations for growth and resilience. The rapid passage of Bill C-5, the “nation-building” legislation, marks a significant achievement for the newly elected Carney government, fulfilling a pledge made during the April federal election. Positioned as a strategic response to external economic threats and internal productivity challenges, Bill C-5 is being heralded as an ambitious and forward-thinking initiative.

Carney’s commitment to enacting Bill C-5 before July 1 was more than a political promise; it was a symbolic gesture of renewal and determination. His government’s ability to shepherd the legislation through both chambers at record speed is seen by many as a testament to effective leadership and the urgency of addressing Canada’s economic imperatives. The bill’s focus on reducing interprovincial trade barriers and fast-tracking projects of national interest aligns with Carney’s vision of economic diversification and strategic autonomy.

News: Carney government’s ‘nation-building’ bill becomes law despite Senate criticism

Ontario's climate targets are at risk due to policy decisions prioritizing economic growth over environmental action, sparking criticism and calls for genuine change.

June 26, 2025

In stark contrast stands Ontario’s Bill 5, the “Protecting Ontario by Unleashing Our Economy Act,” which, despite being similarly focused on economic development, has attracted substantial criticism. The Ford government’s initiative is perceived by many as prioritizing economic growth at the expense of environmental safeguards and Indigenous rights. This perception is compounded by the government’s previous record, which has often been criticized for insufficient consultation and environmental stewardship. Although Ford received a mandate in a recent provincial election, the low voter turnout suggests a more tepid endorsement of his policies.

The comparatively positive reception of Carney’s Bill C-5 can be attributed, in part, to a sense of optimism and faith in a government that, as of yet, remains untested in its stewardship of the environment and commitment to meaningful consultation. The Carney administration’s promises of full-day engagement sessions with Indigenous rights holders and its emphasis on consultation reflect a desire to balance economic progress with social responsibility. This assurance, coupled with Carney’s credentials in sustainable finance and economic expertise, fosters a belief that his government can navigate the complex intersections of development and rights protection.

News: Senate passes Carney’s signature bill to fast-track major projects

Ontario's Bills 5 and 14, alongside federal Bill C-5, raise concerns about the lack of meaningful consultation with Indigenous communities, risking economic progress and trust.

June 17, 2025

While Bill C-5’s passage is a significant milestone, the real test lies ahead in its implementation. The government must ensure that the rhetoric of consultation translates into genuine dialogue and that the fast-tracking of projects does not sideline environmental and Indigenous concerns. The presence of oversight mechanisms and reporting requirements in the legislation offers some reassurance, yet vigilance from all stakeholders remains crucial.

As Canada reflects on its past and looks to its future this Canada Day, the swift enactment of Bill C-5 serves as a reminder of the possibilities inherent in bold leadership and strategic vision. While the Carney government’s record is still in the making, the potential for nation-building is palpable. It is a moment of hope and promise, one that invites Canadians to participate in shaping a future that honours both economic ambition and the values of inclusivity and sustainability.

Happy Canada Day. Have some cake, err, or some pie

It’s amazing how quickly the Mark Carney government managed to pass the ‘nation-building’ Bill C-5, just as he promised before Canada Day. This was the gift he pledged after the Liberals’ victory in the April federal election, and he’s delivered on it. When you compare this to Ontario’s Bill 5, the “Protecting Ontario by Unleashing Our Economy Act,” there’s a noticeable difference in public perception.

Ontario’s Bill 5 is facing much more criticism, likely because the Ford government doesn’t have a stellar record on environmental matters and consultation. Despite receiving a mandate in a recent election, the low voter turnout suggests a lack of strong backing.

Part of why Carney’s Bill C-5 is being received more positively might be due to his image as a capable and trusted CEO figure. People seem to have faith in his leadership, even though his government is untested in areas like environmental stewardship and proper consultation. On the other hand, Doug Ford is often seen as more of a lovable bumbler, which might affect how his policies are perceived.

Ultimately, when it comes to consultation, there needs to be a limit. It’s important to ensure that projects are scrutinized to minimize risks, but not to the point where development is completely blocked. There’s a fine line between being cautious and being overly restrictive, and finding that balance is key.

Why the Canada Day cartoon so early, you ask? I’m taking my usual time off during the first week of July and won’t be drawing anything for the Tuesday holiday. In the past, this time off included typical Canada Day celebrations, perhaps at a friend’s pool or a cottage, followed by a trip south to celebrate the Fourth of July with American family and friends. Sadly, this year is different due to ongoing issues caused by you know who…

If you haven’t already, please subscribe to my Substack newsletter, where I share weekly editorial cartoons every Saturday morning. Substack is a vital platform for me, especially in the face of recent layoffs and newspaper closures impacting our industry. Don’t miss my animated editorial cartoon for June 28, 2025, below!

YouTube: https://youtu.be/4AKh2KiZ3tw

– The Graeme Gallery

Read on Substack

Saturday June 21, 2025

As Canada grapples with trade tensions, wildfire threats, and climate neglect, the promise of summer offers a glimmer of hope and respite.

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Saturday June 21, 2025

Tariffs, Flames, and Summer Games: A Season of Surprises

December 20, 2022

As the summer solstice approaches on June 21, 2025, we find ourselves at a pivotal moment marked by significant political and environmental timelines. This longest day of the year, with its promise of extended daylight and warmer days, serves as a powerful metaphor for the varied and often conflicting timelines that shape our current reality.

In Canada, the government’s response to U.S. tariffs on steel and aluminum has been met with criticism from industry leaders. Prime Minister Mark Carney has outlined a 30-day window to adjust counter-tariffs, dependent on progress in trade negotiations with President Donald Trump’s administration. This timeline reflects an urgent need to protect Canadian industries while dealing with the complexities of international diplomacy. However, the Canadian steel producers and workers express dissatisfaction, arguing that the measures fall short of addressing the crisis.

News: Steel industry groups say Carney’s retaliatory plan for U.S. tariffs ‘falls short’

Ontario's Bills 5 and 14, alongside federal Bill C-5, raise concerns about the lack of meaningful consultation with Indigenous communities, risking economic progress and trust.

June 17, 2025

Simultaneously, the passage of Bill C-5 looms large, threatening to strain relations between the Canadian government and First Nations communities. The Assembly of First Nations has voiced strong opposition, citing inadequate consultation and potential infringement on treaty rights. The potential for a “long, hot summer” of protests highlights the urgency and gravity of this issue.

Across the border, President Trump’s penchant for two-week timelines has become a hallmark of his administration. Whether it’s decisions on Iran, trade policies, or domestic issues, this timeline often serves as a placeholder, creating uncertainty and anticipation. While it allows for strategic flexibility, it also leaves allies and adversaries alike in a state of limbo, uncertain of the U.S.’s next moves.

News: A familiar metric: White House says to expect Iran decision within ‘two weeks’

July 29, 2023

As we stand on the cusp of summer, these timelines intersect with the broader context of a warming climate. Recent scenes of hellacious wildfires in Canada’s western provinces have underscored the immediate and devastating impact of climate change. These fires have ravaged landscapes and communities, serving as a stark reminder that more such events are likely in the months to come. The season brings with it the expected perils of wildfires, heatwaves, and extreme weather, underscoring the need for decisive action on climate change.

Disturbingly, despite the G7 meeting taking place just a few hundred kilometres from the whiffs of burning embers, the topic of climate change was not even offered up for discussion. This omission highlights a glaring disconnect between the urgent realities on the ground and the political agenda at the highest levels.

Trump's early departure from the G7 Summit raises questions about U.S. commitment to global affairs and leaves other leaders to navigate critical discussions without him.

June 18, 2025

Yet, amid these challenges, there remains the hope and anticipation of summer vacations—a respite from the weight of decision-making and the relentless pace of news cycles. This summer, as we face these varied timelines, we are reminded of the delicate balance between urgency and patience, between action and reflection. The solstice, with its ancient traditions and astronomical significance, offers a moment to pause and consider how we can align our timelines with the natural rhythms of the Earth.

News: When is the summer solstice and what is it?

In a world fraught with uncertainty, the promise of warmer days and longer evenings invites us to find solace in the simple pleasures of summer. Whether it’s a moment of quiet reflection at dawn, a gathering with friends around a bonfire, or a long-anticipated vacation, let us embrace the season with a renewed sense of hope and purpose. As we await the decisions that will shape our future, may we find the courage to act with wisdom and the grace to savour the present.