C-5

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Tuesday June 17, 2025

The Need for Inclusive Governance

In a time when quick progress is often seen as vital for economic growth, the introduction of Bills 5 (Better Municipal Governance Act) and 14 in Ontario, along with the federal Bill C-5 (One Canadian Economy Act), raises important concerns about how fast-tracking decisions can affect Indigenous rights and local governance. While these bills aim to streamline processes and promote economic development, the lack of meaningful consultation with Indigenous communities and other levels of government could undermine the very progress they intend to achieve.

At first glance, Bills 5 and C-5 seem to have similar goals, both designed to enhance economic growth and simplify decision-making. However, introducing federal and provincial legislation simultaneously can create confusion among those affected regarding their specific impacts and the consultation processes involved. In a competitive economy, the need to attract investment and create jobs is clear. Yet, rushing to put these laws in place without engaging with impacted communities creates an environment filled with tension and conflict.

News: Chiefs of Ontario decry lack of consultation on Bill C-5

The main issue is that insufficient consultation can lead to significant problems. When Indigenous communities are not meaningfully involved in decisions that affect their lands and resources, they may feel excluded and distrustful of government actions. This can lead to protests and opposition, as seen with the planned rallies against Bills 5 and C-5. Additionally, failing to consult properly can result in legal challenges, as Indigenous leaders have indicated that they will take action if their rights are overlooked. This can delay projects and deepen historical tensions between Indigenous communities and governments.

Consultation is not just a legal obligation; it can also lead to better outcomes for everyone involved. Indigenous communities often have valuable knowledge about land management and environmental stewardship that can improve project results. Ignoring their input is not only unfair but can also hinder economic progress. Moreover, the urgency to pass these bills might come from a desire to avoid controversy, which can appear autocratic and alienate constituents who feel their voices are not valued. Good governance requires open dialogue and compromise.

News: Anishinabek Nation chief says he briefed Ontario police on protests against Bill 5

As Ontario faces the challenges of economic development, the need for genuine consultation with Indigenous communities and other stakeholders is more important than ever. The introduction of Bills 5 and 14, along with federal Bill C-5, reflects a push for progress, but without proper consultation, we risk damaging the trust and cooperation necessary for sustainable development. To build an economy that respects the rights and voices of all Canadians, both the Ontario government and the federal government must prioritize dialogue and compromise. Only through real engagement can we create a future that honours Indigenous rights and promotes a fair and prosperous society for everyone.

---