commentary

Friday August 24, 2018

August 24, 2018

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Friday August 24, 2018

Ontario government says it has an interim sex-ed curriculum elementary teachers must follow

February 14, 2018

The Ontario government has released an interim sex-ed curriculum for elementary school teachers to use this September, and Premier Doug Ford is suggesting there will be consequences if they don’t adhere to it.

The Elementary Teachers’ Federation of Ontario (ETFO) was quick to blast the plan, accusing the Ford government of creating chaos instead of addressing the real issues facing the public school system just weeks before classes resume.

The Progressive Conservative government issued a news release about the changes on Wednesday afternoon, while also announcing plans for what it called an “unprecedented” provincewide consultation process on education reform and a future parents’ bill of rights.

September 10, 2015

The Ford government has faced sharp criticism from a number of groups — including teachers’ unions, many parents and the Official Opposition — over its decision to scrap the modernized sex-ed curriculum brought in by the former Liberal government in 2015, which included information about online bullying, sexting and gender identity.

A group of human rights lawyers are also challenging the government’s decision in court on behalf of six families.

Neither Ford nor Education Minister Lisa Thompson took questions from reporters on Wednesday. (Source: CBC News) 

In offending readers, cartoon made its point

We are in the business of publishing content, not suppressing it, writes Paul Berton

Graeme MacKay’s editorial cartoon last weekend caused a predictable fuss.

When it was brought to my attention before publication, I laughed out loud, and immediately recognized it would be problematic.

Indeed, some readers called it vulgar, another was disgusted and saddened, and said the paper “has sunk to the level of a tabloid.” One writer didn’t like the fact that it seemed to mock Ontario Premier Doug Ford, and added that he didn’t like it either when MacKay made fun of “our president.”

Why did we print it?

I could talk about the freedom of the press, the unique ability of satire to get to essence of an issue, or the importance of reflecting different points of view, and I could remind you that a cartoonist’s views are not necessarily those of the newspaper,

although sometimes they are. In the case of The Spectator, MacKay’s views are his own.

Or we could have just killed the cartoon, arguing that any reference to a penis in connection with Ontario’s premier is inappropriate, even if it is in the context of a heated debate over the future of sex education in the province.

We could have decided our readers don’t need that kind of thing at breakfast, let alone lunch or dinner. But that too, is the heart of the matter — and the point of the cartoon.

Ultimately, we are in the business of publishing content, not suppressing it. There have been times in the past when I thought I should have prevented something from publication, but in retrospect, I regret far more often the things we didn’t print than those we did.

Besides, if we had spiked that cartoon, we would have denied many other readers the laugh that I and others experienced from it, and laughs these days are all too rare.

For not only did we receive complaints about the cartoon, we also received kudos in their wake. You can turn to today’s letters-to-the-editor for some evidence of that. It is human nature to complain, but compliments are much less common.

Such supporters realize a good cartoonist never takes the issue as seriously as those in the midst of it — politicians usually, but often anyone in authority. True, cartoons often say in pictures what some of us are too polite to say in words, but they also make us look in the mirror, point out obvious or sometimes hidden inanities, and poke fun at people who take themselves too earnestly.

Any newspaper editor who says an editorial cartoonist doesn’t cause her or him grief is probably lying. It has always an uncomfortable relationship, and indeed, some cartoonists have been fired for their views. It would be easier for newspaper editors if nobody ever called to complain, but then we’d be approaching irrelevance.

Fortunately, Spec readers care deeply about this news organization, many of you think of us as part of the family, and feel a personal connection. We appreciate that, and we encourage all complaints, considered arguments and feedback of any sort. (Source)

Paul Berton is editor-in-chief of The Hamilton Spectator and thespec.com. You can reach him at 905-526-3482 or pberton@thespec.com

SaveSave

SaveSaveSaveSaveSaveSave

SaveSave

Monday July 16, 2018

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Monday July 16, 2018

McCain: Trump’s meeting with Putin ‘should not move forward’

December 17, 2016

Sen. John McCain praised the Department of Justice’s announcement of the indictment of 12 Russian intelligence officers for interfering in the 2016 presidential election, adding President Donald Trump shouldn’t meet with Russian President Vladimir Putin unless he holds him accountable.

“President Trump must be willing to confront Putin from a position of strength and demonstrate that there will be a serious price to pay for his ongoing aggression towards the United States and democracies around the world,” the Arizona senator said in a statement Friday. “If President Trump is not prepared to hold Putin accountable, the summit in Helsinki should not move forward.”

November 3, 2017

The statement came hours after the Justice Department announced indictments against 12 Russian nationals as part of special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation of Russian interference in the 2016 election, accusing them of engaging in a “sustained effort” to hack Democrats’ emails and computer networks.

Trump is due to meet Russian President Vladimir Putin — who has denied election meddling — in Helsinki on Monday for a summit that includes a one-on-one meeting with only interpreters present.

March 7, 2017

McCain wasn’t the only Republican senator to criticize Putin following the indictments. Nebraska Sen. Ben Sasse said in a statement that “all patriotic Americans” should know Putin is not “the President’s buddy.”

“The US intelligence community knows that the Russian government attacked the US,” he said in a statement. “This is not a Republican or a Democrat view — it is simply the reality. All patriotic Americans should understand that Putin is not America’s friend, and he is not the President’s buddy. We should stand united against Putin’s past and planned future attacks against us.” (Source: CNN) 

Comic Strip of the Day, July 14, 2018

SaveSave

The 2018 Ontario Election

The Writ Drops

The coming provincial election promises to be an interesting one. At Queen’s Park, Premier Kathleen Wynne has controlled the levers of an unpopular government since 2013, that, combined with 10 years of Dalton McGuinty’s tenure, adds up to 15 years of rule by Ontario Liberals. The projected net debt is at an all time high of $325 billion (compared with $138 billion when Liberals assumed power in 2003). The debt to GDP ratio is approaching 40%. Hydro costs have ballooned under the Liberals, and despite efforts to tackle emergency ward wait times, hospitals continue to be overcrowded. Falling grades are indicating a decline in Ontario’s education, and transit projects aren’t keeping pace with congested 400 series highways. The combined corruption storms resulting from the McGuinty years regarding gas plant emails, and the Sudbury by-election bribery case haven’t helped matters for the current Liberal leader.

The unpopularity problem

The election results of 2014 clearly showed that voters were intent on forgiving the Liberals for their many misdeeds and confident its new leader Kathleen Wynne would build the trust and good government that had been lost in the dying years of McGuinty’s reign. Ontario voters even rewarded the new leader with a majority victory in 2014, after slapping the previous one down with a slim minority. This is often forgotten in the current #metoo climate when supporters of Kathleen Wynne deal the misogyny and homophobe cards to explain her dreary popularity numbers. 

Polls consistently show that voters are done with Kathleen Wynne (ranked as the least popular Premier in Canada), and indeed the Liberal government in Ontario. To answer this, the Liberal Party platform is chock-a-block full of big spending progressive (NDPesque) promises for child care, health care, senior support, and dental and pharmacare. Despite the efforts, the mood among comment boards, call-in shows, and letters to the editor, seem to be very much about “throwing the bums out”. If, at this point the Liberal’s defeat is quite certain, then the question of who wins and by how much remains to be answered.

The numbers problem

Andrea Horwath enters her 3rd provincial election leading the NDP with poll numbers matching the governing Liberals. After attempting to make her party more palatable to centrist and Liberal Party voters in 2014, while outraging the most leftie members in the process, she has steered the party back to its traditional NDP position with campaign promises embracing free dental care, free tuition, and undoing Kathleen Wynne’s privatization of Hydro.

The populism problem

As big spending platforms rule the day on the left with the Liberals and NDP, the Doug Ford PCs are the very opposite. Even with no platform to run on the Tories are banking on poll numbers that are 15% plus above the numbers of either competitor. They are assumed to be the winning player in the game to take power back, to trumpet fiscal prudence, reining in spending, cutting away public services, and doling out incentives to business’ and wealthy folk.

Hastily assuming the leadership of the PCs beset by scandal and malaise under Patrick Brown, Doug Ford seems to have used populist energy to recharge a party lacking confidence in direction. With new leadership comes learning, and based on the amount of sloganeering dished out by Doug Ford, and an increasingly obvious dearth in policy expertise, or even knowledge (i.e.: how a bill becomes law), it’s becoming evident by the day that the presumptive Premier requires a steep learning curve to adequately prepare himself for the top job. It’s merely a matter of time before we find out if Doug Ford just managed to be the right person at the right time, no matter how uninformed he proves himself to be.

At this point there’s no betting on who will be in charge at the pink palace after June 7, 2018. The PCs may now be riding high in the polls, but its leader is just one gaffe away from throwing the party’s support away in the same way John Tory did with faith based schools, or Tim Hudak did with his one million jobs gimmick. What is predictable about the coming 4 weeks are polls that will turn out to be way off reality. Nothing can really forecast how strategic voting will factor on election day, not to mention, the no shows: declining participation of the electorate, which has been dropping with each ballot, and was below 50% in 2014.  There’s no predicting the outcome of this election. It really is anyone’s game. 

1995 – 2014 Election retrospective

2014
2014
2014
2014
2014
2011
2011
2011
2007
2007
2007
2003
2003
2003
2003
1999
1999
1995

 

2014 Ontario Election (Click Here)
SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSaveSaveSave

SaveSave

Wednesday September 13, 2017

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Wednesday September 13, 2017

Jagmeet Singh praised for ‘calm and positive’ reaction to anti-Muslim heckler

Federal NDP leadership hopeful Jagmeet Singh is garnering praise for the way he reacted to a woman who accused him last week of supporting Islamic extremism, because he chose to come out against “all forms of hate” instead of emphasizing that he is Sikh rather than Muslim.

August 3, 2017

The Ontario MPP was interrupted by an angry heckler at a meet and greet last Wednesday in Brampton, Ont. The woman stood in front of the candidate and shouted as aides tried to usher her aside in an incident that was caught on video and shared widely on social media well beyond Canada’s borders.

The woman accused Singh of wanting to impose Shariah law, an Islamic legal code based on the Qur’an, and supporting the Muslim Brotherhood, an 89-year-old religious and political group. The exchange was caught on video and lasted more than four minutes.

“Many people have commented that I could have just said I’m not Muslim. In fact, many have clarified that I’m actually Sikh,” Singh explained in a statement.  

“While I’m proud of who I am, I purposely didn’t go down that road because it suggests their hate would be OK if I was Muslim.”

A political science professor told CBC News on Monday that Singh took the right approach.

“It suggests the fact that he is not Muslim is irrelevant,” said Erin Tolley, an assistant professor at the University of Toronto.

“You can just imagine for example a white politician standing in front of a room and heard something racist being said. The exact wrong reaction is to say, ‘Well, I’m white, I’m not a person of colour, so this isn’t important to me.’”

Singh wanted to defuse the situation, she said, highlighting that hate of all forms is wrong, whether it’s directed at your community or not.

His response also signals that Singh, who wears a turban, has experience dealing with direct threats because of his outwardly religious appearance.  (Source: CBC News) 


This cartoon received an unusual amount of criticism through the mackaycartoons Facebook Page: 


Republished in a number of publications. Below the Edmonton Journal and the Western Star, Corner Brook, Newfoundland:

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

Thursday February 18, 2016

 

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator Ð Thursday February 18, 2016 Canada to lose 2,830 jobs as Bombardier slashes workforce Bombardier Inc. says it will cut 7,000 positions over the next two years including 2,000 contractors in both aerospace and train divisions Ð almost 10 per cent of its global work force. Most of the job losses will be in Canada and Europe, but will be partly offset by hiring in certain growth areas as production ramps up for the new CSeries aircraft. ÒWe are taking this difficult decision to make Bombardier strong,Ó said Bombardier CEO Alain Bellemare on a conference call with analysts on Wednesday after reporting weak fourth quarter earnings. The Montreal-based aerospace and rail equipment company says the cuts will begin in the coming weeks and be completed by 2017. It was not immediately clear where the job cuts will be, though 2,830 will be in Canada. Of those, 430 will be in Ontario and 2,400 in Quebec. In Canada, 400 jobs will be eliminated in the transportation division and 2,430 in the aerospace division. Transport Minister Marc Garneau says he has mixed feelings about the job cuts and the Air Canada deal. The minister sang the praises of BombardierÕs new aircraft, but he did not immediately commit to helping the troubled company out of its financial difficulties. The Quebec government is putting up $1 billion (U.S.) for a 49.5 per cent stake in the CSeries program, while the Caisse de depots et placement du Quebec, the pension plan, spent $1.5 billion (U.S.) for a 30 per cent stake in the companyÕs train division. Bombardier has asked the federal government to join in with financial assistance for the CSeries, but like Garneau, Navdeep Bains, minister of innovation, science and economic development, said Ottawa is still studying the idea. ÒAny action the government takes with respect to Bombardier will be first and foremost in the interest of Canadians,Ó Bains said in a statement. ÒWe have been clear th

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Thursday February 18, 2016

Canada to lose 2,830 jobs as Bombardier slashes workforce

Bombardier Inc. says it will cut 7,000 positions over the next two years including 2,000 contractors in both aerospace and train divisions – almost 10 per cent of its global work force.

Most of the job losses will be in Canada and Europe, but will be partly offset by hiring in certain growth areas as production ramps up for the new CSeries aircraft.

“We are taking this difficult decision to make Bombardier strong,” said Bombardier CEO Alain Bellemare on a conference call with analysts on Wednesday after reporting weak fourth quarter earnings.

The Montreal-based aerospace and rail equipment company says the cuts will begin in the coming weeks and be completed by 2017.

 

It was not immediately clear where the job cuts will be, though 2,830 will be in Canada. Of those, 430 will be in Ontario and 2,400 in Quebec.

In Canada, 400 jobs will be eliminated in the transportation division and 2,430 in the aerospace division.

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator - Friday February 12, 2016 Trudeau shies away from Liberals' balanced-budget vow, cites fading economy Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is backing away from a campaign vow to balance the public books before the end of his government's four-year mandate Ñ a promise that was central to the Liberal election platform. As a result of a weakening economy, the government's upcoming 2016-17 budget plan will show a deficit larger than the Liberals' promised $10-billion shortfall cap, Trudeau told Montreal's La Presse newspaper. Just how big that deficit will be remains unclear. If the economy continues to deteriorate, it will be difficult for the Liberals to live up to their pledge to balance the books in 2019-20, Trudeau said in an interview published Thursday. Less than two months ago, Trudeau insisted that the Liberal plan to make good on that key balanced-budget promise was "very" cast in stone. The doubts raised by Trudeau offer a glimpse of the fiscal pressure faced by the Finance Department as it crafts the government's first federal budget, expected late next month. "If we look at the growth projections for the next three or four years, it will be difficult (to return to balance)," Trudeau was quoted by La Presse as saying. "But everything we're doing is aimed at creating economic growth. When predicting the level of growth four years in advance, governments often miss the target." During the fall election campaign, Trudeau promised to keep deficits below the $10-billion mark in 2016-17 and 2017-18 unless the economic situation got radically worse. "Yes, we will go over $10 billion," Trudeau told La Presse. "By how much? We are in the process of examining that." In recent months, the Canadian economy has sputtered in large part due to the steep drop in commodity prices. On Wednesday, a National Bank of Canada report said the country's fading economic prospects could put the Liberal government on tra

Friday February 12, 2016

Transport Minister Marc Garneau says he has mixed feelings about the job cuts and the Air Canada deal.

The minister sang the praises of Bombardier’s new aircraft, but he did not immediately commit to helping the troubled company out of its financial difficulties.

The Quebec government is putting up $1 billion (U.S.) for a 49.5 per cent stake in the CSeries program, while the Caisse de depots et placement du Quebec, the pension plan, spent $1.5 billion (U.S.) for a 30 per cent stake in the company’s train division.

Bombardier has asked the federal government to join in with financial assistance for the CSeries, but like Garneau, Navdeep Bains, minister of innovation, science and economic development, said Ottawa is still studying the idea.

“Any action the government takes with respect to Bombardier will be first and foremost in the interest of Canadians,” Bains said in a statement. “We have been clear that such an important decision will only be made after due diligence, careful consideration and a strong business case.”

Bellemare said federal investment is very important because it would provide “a strong endorsement on the program itself.” As well, it would bring additional financial flexibility to support sale campaigns and production. (Source: Toronto Star)

 

SOCIAL MEDIA & OTHER PRESS

Discussion thread on in French on Reddit, and a slightly different tone in the comments also on Reddit.

Ottawa Citizen, February 22, 2016

Ottawa Citizen, February 22, 2016