Wednesday March 6, 2024
Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Wednesday March 6, 2024
The Vital Role of Vaccines in Preventing Measles
The recent surge in measles cases in Canada, particularly in Montreal, underscores the urgent need to address vaccine hesitancy and combat anti-vaccine conspiracy theories, with historical evidence emphasizing the proven efficacy of vaccines in preventing disease and protecting public health.
News: Quebec reports 10 cases of measles in Montreal area, health officials urge vaccinations
The recent resurgence of measles in Quebec, with ten confirmed cases in Greater Montreal, serves as a stark reminder of the critical role vaccines play in public health. This outbreak, now the epicentre of a Canadian concern, has ignited discussions about the root causes, and it seems that vaccine hesitancy, fuelled by anti-vaccine conspiracy theories, is a significant factor.
As health officials scramble to contain the outbreak, the words of Quebec Public Health Director Luc Boileau echo with urgency. He warns that the disease could rapidly spread among the unvaccinated, emphasizing the need for swift action to address the situation. While Quebec currently does not mandate vaccination, the emphasis is on providing information, facilitating access to shots, and dispelling misconceptions.
The efficacy of vaccines, especially against measles, has been proven over the past 50 years. Dr. Caroline Quach-Thanh, a paediatrician and infectious disease specialist, emphasizes the safety, efficiency, and quick action of the measles vaccine. Yet, despite decades of evidence supporting vaccination, a significant challenge remains – vaccine hesitancy.
In Montreal and its suburbs, vaccination coverage in schools hovers around 80%, below the 95% required to prevent community transmission. The reasons are varied, from delays in translating foreign vaccination records to vaccine hesitancy, a phenomenon exacerbated by limited access for newly arrived children.
The virus’s high contagion rate, coupled with potential complications, especially in young children, underscores the importance of immunization. The harm extends beyond the individual; the immune-compromised face severe consequences, making vaccination not just a personal choice but a communal responsibility.
The historical success of vaccines, including the measles vaccine, should guide our present actions. However, the current landscape is clouded by misinformation and skepticism, particularly regarding COVID-19 vaccines. The rise in anti-vaccine sentiment, as evidenced by the unfounded chatter on social media, suggests a broader problem.
A simple fact-checking response might aid in emphasing the importance of relying on scientific evidence and expert consensus, and not on quackery baked up in Tik-Toks and You Tube clip served up by snake oil agents. It counters the notion that mRNA vaccines, a breakthrough in the fight against COVID-19, are ineffective or overhyped. The evidence points to the contrary, highlighting the role of mRNA technology in reducing mortality rates and controlling the virus’s spread.
As we grapple with the resurgence of measles and the challenges posed by vaccine hesitancy, the message is clear – vaccines save lives. The current outbreak should serve as a call to action, not just to address immediate concerns but to tackle the root causes of hesitancy and misinformation. In a world where viruses don’t develop resistance to vaccines, the path to overcoming outbreaks is through widespread and informed vaccination. (AI)
Letter to the Editor, The Hamilton Spectator, March 11, 2024
Vaccinations and our rights
The return of measles, which can be deadly or leave serious side effect like deafness, reveals that a major portion of the population is unvaccinated, especially children. As with COVID-19, those refusing vaccination on the basis of their democratic right of freedom ignore what democracy is about. Democracy indeed allows for freedom of ideas, speech, choice, movement, but equally, and the “no vaccines” crowd ignore it, is that these rights may not be exercised should they imperil other members of society or their rights.
You may think what you wish, but you may not spout hatred, not vocally nor in the media, nor in print, nor in blasting truck horns all night. You may not pull together enough fellow bigots to bring in voting regulations which deny the vote to fellow citizens, as we have witnessed in some U.S. states. You may not endanger the health of your fellow citizens; thus anti-pollution laws. Under freedom of choice, these non-thinkers are rejecting vaccination, a treatment to control an incredibly infectious disease which threatens all democratic rights, and because they continue to move about freely, they endanger the lives of fellow democratic citizens. In practice, I reject autocracy totally, but recognize the sneakily cynical thought that tyrants have one advantage, they can enforce essentials. Unfortunately, they cannot enforce intelligence. Equally unfortunate, there is no vaccine for pig-headed stupidity.
Dr. Helen Hatton, Hamilton