Tuesday March 25, 2025

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Tuesday March 25, 2025
Playing the Trump Card: A Conservative Gamble
The first week of the 2025 federal election has been anything but smooth for the Conservative Party, as Alberta Premier Danielle Smith’s recent actions and comments have cast an unwelcome spotlight on the party and its leader, Pierre Poilievre. Her controversial request to the Trump administration to pause tariffs until after the Canadian election has not only raised eyebrows but has also thrown a wrench into the Conservatives’ campaign strategy.
Smith’s actions, perceived by many as an invitation for foreign interference in Canadian politics, have drawn widespread criticism. Her alignment with Donald Trump, underscored by her visit to Mar-a-Lago and attendance at Trump’s inauguration, plays the “Trump card,” bending the narrative of her loyalty and fuelling concerns about a lack of commitment to Canadian interests. In a time when unity and a cohesive national strategy are paramount, Smith’s independent approach undermines the collective “Team Canada” stance that both provincial and federal leaders strive to present.
Opinion: Canada, May I Introduce You to Ukraine?
Trump’s penchant for describing perceived weakness as not “holding the cards” is particularly relevant here. By aligning with Trump, Smith may inadvertently align with this narrative of vulnerability, casting doubts on her and Poilievre’s ability to lead with strength and independence. This association could paint the Conservatives as lacking the strategic “cards” needed to effectively govern and protect Canadian interests.
For Pierre Poilievre, this association with Trump-like politics is a significant hurdle. As he attempts to broaden his appeal to a diverse electorate, Smith’s comments and actions risk reinforcing a narrative that ties him closely to Trump—a narrative that could alienate moderate and swing voters who are wary of such connections. Poilievre’s reluctance to distance himself from Smith’s remarks only complicates his efforts to rebrand the Conservative Party and distance it from the divisive politics of the past.
Opinion: Danielle Smith’s Trump talk threatens Pierre Poilievre’s chances to win
Liberal Leader Mark Carney has capitalized on this situation, emphasizing the need for a unified government that stands firm for Canada. This contrast between Carney’s vision and the discord within the Conservative ranks could prove pivotal in swaying undecided voters. The controversy surrounding Smith provides the Liberals with a powerful narrative to question the Conservatives’ commitment to Canadian sovereignty and unity.
As the election progresses, the Conservatives face the daunting task of addressing these challenges head-on. Poilievre must navigate the delicate balance of retaining support from his conservative base while reaching out to a broader audience. He needs to clearly articulate his vision for Canada, one that resonates with voters seeking stability and leadership untainted by foreign influence.
The first week of the 2025 federal election has not gone as planned for the Conservatives. Danielle Smith’s missteps have cast a long shadow, complicating Pierre Poilievre’s path to victory. As the campaign unfolds, the Conservatives must work tirelessly to overcome this narrative and present a united front that truly reflects Canadian values and priorities. Whether they can successfully pivot from this challenging start remains to be seen, but the stakes have never been higher.