UK referendum

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Thursday June 25, 2026

Also published in The Toronto Star.

Alberta’s Separation: Lessons from Brexit’s Decade of Discontent

As Alberta approaches its referendum on independence, the echoes of Brexit’s tumultuous journey remind us of the profound implications such decisions can have. Ten years after the UK’s decision to leave the EU, we stand at a crossroads that demands careful consideration of both history and the present context.

Brexit has shown us that promises of swift and utopian change are often misleading. The economic disruptions, trade complications, and social divides that followed the UK’s departure from the EU serve as a cautionary tale for Alberta. While some Albertans feel alienated from Ottawa, the practical realities of separation could lead to prolonged economic uncertainty and legal complexities. The recent article by Marieke Walsh underscores Prime Minister Mark Carney’s view that separatist promises are a “dangerous bluff.” This sentiment is echoed by the broader Canadian public, with a recent Abacus poll revealing that 76% of Canadians outside Alberta want the province to remain in Canada.

News: Carney taps new adviser to lead response to Alberta separatism

Addressing the root causes of this separatist sentiment is crucial. Carney’s appointment of Morgan Breitkreutz as a senior special adviser reflects a strategic move to acknowledge Alberta’s grievances while promoting unity. It’s a recognition that Alberta’s concerns are legitimate and deserve a robust response that goes beyond rhetoric. The sentiment among Albertans, highlighted by Janet Brown’s polling, indicates that while separatist support is significant, a majority still prefer to remain within Canada. 

Analysis: How Brexit broke British politics

To bridge the divide, tangible actions are required. The federal government’s memorandum of understanding with Alberta aims to unlock fossil fuel resources and spur economic growth. These initiatives must yield visible results to reassure Albertans that their voices are heard and their contributions valued.

The Brexit experience teaches us that decisions of such magnitude should not be driven by emotions or temporary discontent. Instead, they require a nuanced understanding of potential consequences. Reader comments from the Globe and Mail article remind us of the complexity involved, highlighting both practical concerns about resource management and the dangers of oversimplifying deep-rooted issues.

Video: 10 years after Brexit and nobody’s happy. (Take notes Alberta)

As Alberta considers its future, the lessons from Brexit are clear. Separation is not a panacea for discontent. By acknowledging grievances and fostering unity through concrete actions, Canada can move forward together, ensuring that its provinces remain strong and interconnected. The path to unity lies in understanding and addressing the real issues, not in promises of an elusive utopia.