governance – mackaycartoons

Saturday April 19, 2025

April 19, 2025 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Saturday April 19, 2025

Poilievre’s Notwithstanding Gamble: A Risky Precedent for Canada

May 4, 2024

In a political landscape increasingly characterized by divisive rhetoric and the erosion of democratic norms, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre’s pledge to invoke the notwithstanding clause of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms is a troubling signal. His proposal to use this powerful constitutional tool to impose consecutive life sentences for multiple murderers may tap into populist sentiments, but it sets a dangerous precedent that should disqualify him and his party from gaining the reins of power.

December 14, 2022

The notwithstanding clause, or Section 33 of the Charter, allows federal and provincial governments to override certain Charter rights temporarily. Traditionally, its use has been confined to provincial matters, such as Quebec’s secularism laws, where it has already sparked controversy. No Canadian Prime Minister has ever used this clause at the federal level, and for good reason. It represents an extraordinary measure intended for exceptional circumstances, not a tool for advancing populist agendas.

December 6, 2022

Poilievre’s willingness to be the first Prime Minister to wield this clause reflects a concerning alignment with tactics seen south of the border under Donald Trump. Trump’s efforts to undermine the judiciary and politicize the courts have led to a weakening of the checks and balances that are foundational to American democracy. Canadians should be wary of similar trends taking root here.

News: Poilievre’s pledge to use notwithstanding clause a ‘dangerous sign’: legal expert

Critics, including legal experts and political leaders, have voiced strong opposition to Poilievre’s plan. They warn that normalizing the use of the notwithstanding clause for routine legislative purposes could erode the Charter’s protections and lead to further politicization of fundamental rights. This slippery slope could extend beyond criminal justice, potentially threatening academic freedom, reproductive rights, and other areas where individual liberties might clash with political agendas.

March 15, 2025

Public sentiment, as reflected in reader comments and broader discourse, reveals deep apprehension about Poilievre’s intentions. The use of the notwithstanding clause is seen not only as an overreach but also as an indication of Poilievre’s authoritarian tendencies—a “trumpy” approach that prioritizes personal opinion over established legal norms. Such a path risks alienating those who value the rule of law and the independence of the judiciary.

News: Poilievre says he’ll use notwithstanding clause to ensure multiple-murderers die in prison

November 9 2024

Poilievre’s tough-on-crime rhetoric may resonate with certain voter bases, but the implications of his proposals extend far beyond immediate policy goals. They strike at the heart of Canada’s democratic values and the delicate balance of power that protects citizens’ rights. As we approach the upcoming election, it is crucial for Canadians to consider the long-term consequences of granting power to a leader willing to circumvent the Charter for political gain.

In a time when global democratic institutions face unprecedented challenges, Canada must stand firm in upholding its principles. Poilievre’s promise to invoke the notwithstanding clause is a stark reminder of the stakes at play. It is a promise that, if fulfilled, could fundamentally alter the landscape of Canadian governance. For this reason, it stands as yet another compelling argument.

“Notwithstanding Clause” no doubt instantly triggers eye glazing in vast swaths of Canadians, a nation where many voters remain unaware of its implications until they feel the impact firsthand. Pierre Poilievre, echoing Trump, is using populist outrage to justify potentially overriding judicial independence with the notwithstanding clause, signalling a troubling shift towards authoritarianism. What might have been seen as fear-mongering before an election becomes irrelevant once a movement takes power. When these accusations no longer trigger instinctive reactions, they solidify into harsh realities. Just look south for proof of this. Timbit Trump’s promise to enforce life sentences by bypassing court decisions raises concerns about future threats to constitutional rights, drawing unsettling parallels with recent U.S. politics. Today, Poilievre targets criminal sentencing, but despite denying admiration for Trump, he emulates many strategies from the Trump playbook, suggesting he might next challenge academic freedom, women’s rights, or other constitutional protections. This commitment to undermining judicial independence to consolidate power is the pivotal issue of this election, as it echoes the U.S. pattern of filling the judiciary with like-minded judges and defying court rulings, reflecting a desire to centralize authority. Sure, just what democracy ordered: another leader eager to override court decisions with his own, thanks to the trusty notwithstanding clause. Vote for this at your peril.

Check out my making-of animated editorial cartoon for April 19, 2025, below! If you haven’t yet, please subscribe to my Substack newsletter, where I share weekly editorial cartoons every Saturday morning. Substack is a crucial platform for me amidst the uncertainties of being a staff cartoonist, especially given recent layoffs and newspaper closures affecting our field. As long as I hold my position, subscriptions will remain free. Thank you for your support! This “note” helps craft my weekly posts and showcases animated versions of my cartoons. Enjoy!

YouTube: Easter Bunny Rejection https://youtu.be/jDyQEaocYGc

– The Graeme Gallery

Read on Substack

Wednesday March 26, 2025

March 26, 2025 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Wednesday March 26, 2025

Ford and Carney: A Pragmatic Duo Navigates Canada’s Challenges

Series: Young Doug Ford

The evolving relationship between Doug Ford and Mark Carney, juxtaposed with the distant rapport Ford shares with Pierre Poilievre, offers a compelling narrative about leadership, pragmatism, and the future of Canadian politics.

Doug Ford, despite his past controversies, has shown a remarkable ability to adapt and work across party lines. His recent collaboration with Mark Carney is a testament to his pragmatic approach. Carney, with his extensive background in economics and leadership, brings a wealth of expertise that complements Ford’s political acumen. Together, they provide a balanced and strategic front against external challenges, particularly in light of Trump’s tariff wars.

News: Insiders say Pierre Poilievre called Doug Ford for ‘advice’ — but the premier said he’ll be ‘staying out’ of the election

January 15, 2025

Their partnership is not just about political convenience; it’s about safeguarding Canadian interests. Ford’s decision to meet with Carney at Wally’s Grill symbolizes a willingness to engage with leaders who share a vision for
In contrast, Pierre Poilievre’s relationship with Ford appears strained and distant. Despite reaching out for advice, Poilievre’s late congratulatory call to Ford and the lack of personal rapport highlight a disconnect. Ford’s focus on governing Ontario and his refusal to engage in federal campaigning further underscores his commitment to provincial priorities.

Poilievre’s rigid stance and divisive rhetoric, reminiscent of American-style politics, seem out of sync with Ford’s centrist approach. This contrast is not lost on voters, many of whom express concerns about Poilievre’s ability to unite and lead effectively.

Opinion: For Doug Ford, Mark Carney will always be a better partner than Pierre Poilievre

April 28, 2023

Reader comments reflect a broader sentiment: Ford, despite his flaws, is viewed as a leader willing to listen and adapt, while Poilievre is seen as rigid and confrontational. Ford’s willingness to collaborate with leaders like Carney, regardless of political affiliation, resonates with Canadians who value cooperation and stability.

In a time of economic uncertainty and external threats, the Ford-Carney alliance offers a reassuring path forward. Their combined leadership exemplifies the power of collaboration and pragmatic governance, positioning Canada to navigate challenges with resilience and foresight.

As Canadians consider their political landscape, the contrast between Ford’s adaptable leadership and Poilievre’s divisive approach becomes increasingly evident. The Ford-Carney partnership stands as a beacon of hope, emphasizing that effective leadership transcends party lines and prioritizes the nation’s well-being.

Picking a Topic

Drawing an editorial cartoon is like putting together a puzzle with a thousand tiny pieces. The hardest part is picking the right topic, especially since my audience is spread across Ontario from Kitchener to Niagara Falls. Today, there were lots of news bites to chew on. The Trump officials’ chat was juicy but already covered by U.S. folks. The TVA debate fee and the India interference story seemed either too niche or not cooked enough yet.

What really caught my eye was the budding bromance between Mark Carney and Doug Ford. Their recent get-togethers offered a perfect chance for some light-hearted fun, especially with a classic CNE setting. I decided to use the “Polar Express” ride to play on Carney’s name and toss in a bit of nostalgia with a young Doug Ford and friends having a blast.

In the cartoon, young Pierre Poilievre looks puzzled in his nerdy “Spirit of 76” shirt, while Carney, as the ride operator, has him talking to the hand. Ford’s on the ride, waving and cheering, while Pierre wonders why he’s left out. The Bulova Tower sneaks into the background, adding that authentic CNE vibe.

This piece is all about mixing humour with a bit of satire, poking fun at political dynamics in a playful way. It feels good to see the idea come to life and hopefully give readers across Ontario a chuckle. Here’s the animated version – Enjoy!

– The Graeme Gallery

Read on Substack

Tuesday March 11, 2025

March 11, 2025 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator –Tuesday March 11, 2025

Carney vs. Populism: Canada’s Crucial Leadership Choice

March 7, 2025

As Canada faces a critical moment, the upcoming election is an important decision for the nation. The biggest challenge is dealing with Donald Trump’s aggressive economic policies, which aim to weaken Canada with tariffs and even suggest annexation. Canadians need to carefully consider the two leading candidates for prime minister: Mark Carney and Pierre Poilievre.

Mark Carney, elected as the Liberal Party leader just yesterday, is new to politics but brings valuable economic experience. As a former head of both the Bank of Canada and the Bank of England, Carney knows how to handle economic challenges, especially with the U.S. pushing hard. His recent speech emphasized Canada’s independence and determination to stand strong, reflecting the national desire to protect our way of life. Carney’s international experience could help Canada build stronger economic ties beyond the U.S.

News: Poilievre and Carney are poised to recreate a legendary Canadian rivalry

February 20, 2025

In contrast, Pierre Poilievre’s approach focuses on populism, using strong rhetoric to rally support. He’s good at connecting with people who feel left out, but there are doubts about his economic skills and how he plans to deal with the challenges from Trump’s administration. Poilievre’s style could energize his supporters but might also divide the country when unity is crucial.

The main challenge for Canada is figuring out how to deal with these tough economic times while keeping the country united. Carney’s approach, focusing on working together and making thoughtful decisions, seems promising. His ability to bring people together and work with others is a big plus in uncertain times.

Editorial: For Mark Carney, now comes the hard part

November 9 2024

As Canadians get ready to vote, it’s important to think beyond party lines and focus on what’s best for the country’s future. The threat from Trump’s policies is something that affects everyone, regardless of politics. In choosing between Carney and Poilievre, Canadians need to consider whether they want a leader with strong economic skills or one who relies on populist appeal.

Ultimately, Canada needs a leader who can inspire confidence, bring people together, and guide the country through these challenges with wisdom. Mark Carney, with his economic know-how and focus on collaboration, might just be the leader Canada needs to stay strong and independent.

As an editorial cartoonist, I try to separate my instincts from the real issues facing our country. Still, I believe Mark Carney is the right choice for Prime Minister. To me, Pierre Poilievre seems like a showman who appeals to a far-right audience that doesn’t reflect Canada’s social values.

Poilievre reminds me of Trump—he denies climate change, rejects working with other countries, flirts with conspiracy theories, and dislikes the media. Canadians have rejected this kind of social conservatism in past elections.

While I’m always cautious about putting too much faith in any leader, Carney’s recent strong support from delegates raises high expectations. He has an impressive background and now, as Prime Minister designate, he must represent all Canadians, not just his party. He needs to unify the nation and assure Conservative voters that he’s the right choice for moving forward.

Carney must also be different from Justin Trudeau, who was often seen as divisive, partly due to Poilievre’s constant criticism. Poilievre’s attempts to appeal to everyone may not convince Canadians he’s the leader to stand up to Trump and defend Canada. Carney, however, has the chance to be a unifying figure.

The cartoon I created reflects this political scene, with the “Captain Canada” superhero suit symbolizing leadership. It humorously highlights the need for a leader who represents the whole country.

Canada is at a crucial point, facing economic challenges and Trump’s tough trade policies. Carney’s strong economic background offers a fresh perspective to guide us toward stability. The upcoming election will show whether Canadians choose economic expertise and collaboration or populist rhetoric. A unifying leader is essential to navigate these challenging times and protect our nation.

Here’s the animated making-of clip of my March 11, 2025 editorial cartoon. I have a huge collection of these on my channel through the YouTube link below.

– The Graeme Gallery

Read on Substack

Saturday February 8, 2025

February 8, 2025 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Saturday February 8, 2025

Accountability over Distraction in Ontario’s Snap Election

February 6, 2025

As Ontario faces challenges from international pressures like those from Donald Trump, Premier Doug Ford has positioned himself as a leader ready to tackle these issues. While his efforts are notable, it’s important to remember that dealing with international trade is mainly a federal responsibility. This raises questions about the timing and focus of the snap election Ford has called.

Elections are a chance to discuss all the issues facing the province. Doug Ford should be held accountable for his record and answer the concerns of Ontarians directly, rather than shifting the focus to figures like Donald Trump.

Ford’s time in office has seen promises to improve housing, infrastructure, healthcare, and affordability. However, many of these promises remain unfulfilled. The ambitious goal of building 1.5 million homes has not been met, and significant infrastructure projects like highways are delayed.

Healthcare is still a major concern, with issues like emergency room closures and doctor shortages continuing, despite promises to increase staffing.

News: With Trump’s tariffs now on hold, will Ontario’s election campaign shift gears?

August 15, 2024

Additionally, Ford’s decisions, such as changes to the Greenbelt and spending on projects like Ontario Place, have led to public dissatisfaction, with many feeling that these actions benefit the wealthy more than the average Ontarian.

Feedback from readers reflects frustration with Ford’s approach to healthcare, education, and cost of living. People feel there’s a lack of understanding and empathy from the Premier.

As voters prepare to vote, it’s crucial to evaluate Doug Ford based on what he has done, not just what he says. The election is a chance for Ford to address these issues directly and offer real solutions, rather than diverting attention to other matters.

Let’s focus on Doug Ford’s track record, hold him accountable for his promises, and demand the action that Ontarians deserve.

By week’s end, TDS had set in, with every cartoon this week fixated on Trump. I know it sounds hypocritical for me, seemingly obsessed with Trump, but I’m a cartoonist, not the Premier. I’m aware of my boundaries, but Doug Ford seems ignorant of the responsibilities he holds within his jurisdiction.

Meanwhile, Ontario’s provincial election quietly began, overshadowed by distractions. It’s as if Ford, like a cartoon hypnotist, swings a pendulum with Trump’s head, putting voters under a spell while pressing issues pile up behind him. Polls show it’s going to work.

As Ontario heads into week two of this election, it’s vital for voters to focus on Ford’s actual governance record, addressing housing, healthcare, and infrastructure challenges, among many other issue. Instead of being swayed by distractions, lets demand real solutions from Ford. I’m hopeful that next week allows for a clearer focus on pressing matters amidst the temporary reprieve from Trump’s theatrics.

Please check out my making-of animated editorial cartoon for February 8, 2025, below! If you haven’t yet, please subscribe to my Substack newsletter, where I release my post every Saturday morning summarizing the week through my editorial cartoons. What you’re reading here is a “note,” designed to help craft my weekly posts and display the animated versions of my daily cartoons. Enjoy!

– The Graeme Gallery

Read on Substack

Wednesday January 8, 2025

January 8, 2025 by Graeme MacKay

Editorial Cartoon by Graeme MacKay, The Hamilton Spectator – Wednesday January 8, 2025

Beyond Trudeau: Charting Canada’s Future in Uncertain Times

January 7, 2025

Justin Trudeau leaves Canadian politics and becomes Canadian history. As he steps down, the nation stands at a crossroads, confronting significant challenges that will define its future. Though Trudeau remains in the role of Prime Minister during a period of prorogation, his influence is waning, and Canada must now navigate a complex landscape of economic, political, and international issues.

The Liberal Party, once rejuvenated under Trudeau’s leadership, is now tasked with finding a new leader amidst internal divisions and dwindling public support. This leadership transition is not merely about choosing a successor but about redefining the party’s vision and restoring confidence among Canadians. The next leader must bridge the gap between Trudeau’s legacy and the electorate’s desire for change, offering a fresh perspective that resonates with a diverse and increasingly skeptical populace.

News: Liberals say no changes coming for leadership race, despite risk of foreign interference

November 21, 2023

Economically, Canada faces a precarious situation. Key policies are stalled, and the potential for a trade war with the United States under President-elect Donald Trump looms large. The uncertainty surrounding future tax policies and the economic impact of halted legislative progress only adds to the anxiety. Canada needs a coherent and robust economic strategy that addresses these challenges, supports growth, and ensures stability for businesses and citizens alike.

On the international stage, Canada’s diplomatic relations are being tested. The nation must assert its position and negotiate effectively to safeguard its interests, particularly in trade agreements and border security. With Trudeau’s departure, there is an opportunity to recalibrate these relationships and engage with global partners in a way that reflects Canada’s values and priorities.

News: Trudeau’s resignation compounds economic uncertainty ahead of possible trade war

June 12, 2024

The issue of electoral integrity also demands attention. The halt of investigations into foreign interference due to prorogation raises questions about the transparency and security of Canada’s democratic processes. Ensuring that future elections and leadership contests are free from undue influence is essential for maintaining public trust and the integrity of Canadian democracy.

The governance void created by prorogation presents an additional challenge, as many cabinet members may shift focus from their crucial governmental duties to pursue leadership ambitions. This distraction occurs at a pivotal time, with the Trump administration’s arrival on January 20 bringing potential shifts in U.S. policy that require a strong and stable Canadian presence. The current political uncertainty and weakened minority government exacerbate the situation, creating a precarious environment where Canada’s national interests could be compromised.

Opinion: A beaten down Trudeau leaves behind a mess that could have been avoided

May 13, 2011

Ultimately, Canada’s path forward requires decisive leadership and a commitment to addressing the pressing issues facing the nation. The moment calls for a leader who can unite the country, implement effective policies, and navigate the complexities of a rapidly changing world. As Canada moves beyond the Trudeau era, it must seize the opportunity to redefine its identity, strengthen its institutions, and chart a course toward a resilient and prosperous future.

The challenges are significant, but so too are the opportunities for renewal and growth. Canada’s next chapter is waiting to be written, and it will take bold vision and collective effort to ensure it is one of progress and success.

It’s a week since 2025 begun and Canada’s political landscape feels like a… you guessed it, a scene from a cartoon—a rickety bus, stalled at the curb, tires flat, with anxious eyes peering out, waiting for a new driver. This isn’t just a metaphor; it’s a vivid illustration of the Liberal Party’s current predicament.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau (who still has the job for at least a couple more months) finds himself at a critical juncture, with his approval ratings at an all-time low and the party’s support waning. The recent departure of key figures like Chrystia Freeland has only intensified the pressure, sparking calls for Trudeau to step down. The whispers of prorogation or a leadership contest are no longer just political gossip—they’re realities.

Meanwhile, the opposition is sharpening its knives. Pierre Poilievre’s Conservatives are ready to pounce, echoing a familiar global refrain: “Everything seems broken.” It’s a mantra that has proven effective elsewhere, notably with Keir Starmer’s Labour triumph in the UK. This rhetoric resonates particularly strongly post-pandemic, as governments worldwide grapple with economic challenges.

Canada isn’t immune. Our national debt continues to climb, productivity lags, and per capita GDP growth isn’t keeping pace. It’s a sobering reality, even if our debt isn’t quite as dire as some G7 counterparts. The prorogation, then, isn’t just a political manoeuvre—it’s a signal that repair is needed.

Adding to this tense atmosphere is the constant chirping from south of the border. President-elect Donald Trump’s comments about Canadian cars and the hypothetical “51st state” status have grown tiresome, casting an unwanted shadow over our period of political renewal.

As the Liberal Party scrambles to recalibrate and potentially select a new leader, Canada waits. The bus may be stopped, but the journey is far from over. The choices made now will shape our nation’s path forward, and like any good cartoon, it’s a story filled with uncertainty, humour, and the hope for a better destination.

Enjoy the January 8, 2024 making-of animated editorial cartoon below. Please subscribe to my Substack newsletter, if you haven’t already. Posts come out every Friday or Saturday as I summarize the week that was in my editorial cartoons. What you’re reading now is regarded as a “note”, which is used to help compose my weekly posts and showcase the animated versions of my daily editorial cartoons.

– The Graeme Gallery

Read on Substack